“Nostalgia is the suffering caused by an unappeased yearning to return,” Milan Kundera, Ignorance
Pick up an American op-ed hostile to rail and somewhere along the way you are likely to read that rail boosters are either technological reactionaries (they want a return to 19th-century technology!), or that they are clouded by nostalgia for a supposed golden age of travel. These criticisms are deceptively powerful, and frequently true. This mentality surely motivates much rail support, especially among the baby-boomer set.
I too have a great personal love for trains. My handy copy of the 1,200-page Complete Guide to the Railways (1954) fills me with something approaching awe. (You mean there used to be service from St. Louis to Mexico City, with connections to Oaxaca?!? Or for that matter, an electrified ride through the Cascades?) The scale of service we have lost in the past 60 years is truly incredible. But it is critically important that as rail advocates we carefully differentiate the sentimental from the sensible.
More after the jump…




