Earlier, I linked to the first details Metro released about RapidRide Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) on the Eastside and to West Seattle. I assumed all the details were the same as for the Pacific Highway segment, but after scrutinizing things more carefully I see I was wrong about that. Metro is promising almost nothing above what we see with a conventional express bus.
Let’s go through Metro’s promises one by one. I’ll use the text from the Eastside line:
After RapidRide service begins, Metro’s plan is for buses to arrive every 10 minutes during the busiest morning and evening travel hours. At other times between 5 a.m. and 10 p.m., buses will come every 15 minutes. Between 10 p.m. and 1 a.m., buses will come every 30 minutes.
We’re talking about less service than Metro route 7. Woo hoo!
RapidRide buses will have low floors and three doors, so people can get on and off quickly. Depending on the outcome of a pilot project, a new fare payment system might be used that would allow riders with passes to pay before they board the bus, and enter through any door.
So we “might” see off-bus payment. I assume they’re referring to ORCA, but doesn’t Metro want to implement that system-wide anyway?
RapidRide stations and stops will be placed where the most riders gather, at reasonable walking distances along the corridor. Bus stops will be farther apart than they are on typical routes, so RapidRide trips will be faster. Metro planners are working with the local communities to choose the best places for stations and stops.
In other words, an express bus. Perhaps you’ve heard of them?
Other features might be added to speed up RapidRide service. For example, as buses approach intersections, they could send signals to traffic lights, requesting that green lights stay green longer or red lights switch to green faster.
It’s nice that they “might” actually do something to actually make the buses run faster. I wonder if that’s contingent on getting more revenue from somewhere, because God forbid that Metro get anything done with a mere $50 million extra per year.
Note what’s not mentioned: any sort of transit-only (or even HOV) lane anywhere along the route. This bus is stuck in the same traffic as the old bus. But it might make a couple of green lights it didn’t before!
All RapidRide stops will be lighted so people can see around themselves and be seen. With buses arriving more often than they do today, people will spend less time waiting at bus stops. Metro Transit Police will be on buses and at bus zones more often for fare enforcement and other security monitoring.
Bus safety is one reason people don’t take transit, but is far behind speed and inconvenience, which this plan does nothing to solve.
At the busiest stops, where many people catch buses each day, Metro will build stations with more room for the expected number of riders. These stations-placed about every mile along the route-will have shelters, benches and trash receptacles. The shelters and signs will look different from those you see at regular Metro stops-they will have a special RapidRide style and color scheme. Waiting areas will be well-lit, increasing security. Electronic realtime signs will tell people the actual number of minutes before the next bus will arrive.
Incidentally, now that they’ve thoughtfully added a legend so that we can actually decode the route map, you can see that not all of the “stops” are actually “stations”. So half the time on this route, you still might be standing next to nothing but a pole in the ground with a route number of it, with no electronic signs, enhanced security, or anything else.
And you can see from the map there are tons of stops, many more than a light rail line would have had. Again, this bus will be anything but “Rapid.”
Between the major stations, RapidRide bus stops also will have signs and other features to give them the distinctive RapidRide look. In some cases shelters and benches may be added or improved. Stop-request signals, which people can use to alert the bus driver when they are waiting for a bus at night, may be provided at these stops.
The buses will be easily recognizable with the RapidRide design and color scheme. All buses will be high-capacity, low-emission hybrid vehicles designed especially for RapidRide.
It’s slow, but at least it’s rebranded! As for nice shelters and so on, what they’re really describing is just bringing up a lot of really crappy Metro stops to some kind of minimum standard. That’s nice and all, but it isn’t a replacement for Light Rail.
In fairness, the West Seattle page adds this:
Other features might be added to speed up West Seattle RapidRide service. Business Access & Transit (BAT) lanes would help buses move faster through the corridor. The City of Seattle is considering transit lanes for portions of work in conjunction with the transit-only lane on SW Spokane Street and the West Seattle Bridge.
It sounds like this depends on other funds from the city rather than the Transit Now package. But hey, it’s better than the Eastside situation.
This is really pathetic. Metro could very easily have hired a few transit cops, spruced up a couple of stops, bought a couple of extra buses, and run a “253 express”. They could have even posted instructions on how to get bus arrival information using the mybus.org SMS service, and gotten about 95% of the benefit for around $1 million. They would also have avoided the confusion that will arise from appearing to add another transit provider to join Metro, Sound Transit, and Community Transit buses operating in this area. And oh yeah, it’ll take till 2011 for this to get realized.
Compare with Community Transit, which was creative with Federal grants and was able to start planning for a superior BRT line without a tax or fare increase. Examples of shoddy projects like this make me wonder why anyone would want to disband Sound Transit and move its responsibilities to the county agencies.
The 0.1% Transit Now levy generates approximately $50 million per year. Collected for 12 years, it would have gotten us half the money required to get to Northgate by 2018! It’s ridiculous to suggest that incremental improvements like these would produce anything like half the effect of the Northgate line.
To argue that Bus Rapid Transit is viable alternative to Light Rail is to insult our intelligence. Won’t someone truly interested in alternatives to sitting in traffic please run against Ron Sims?

Wow. I’m so glad I voted yes. Well, apparently the state auditory said that Sound Transit is in the “Good Camp” when it comes to cooperating. Which camp do you think he’d lump Metro into?
Sound Transit is very effective in getting projects completed! It is no suprise to me that ST keeps getting excellent audit ratings. Joni Earl has made this a well oiled machine! That is pretty significant given where they stood prior to her taking over. I think that ST does a much better job an communicating with the public than Metro does. Metro definitely has issues. Yes, I am going to say it: it starts at the very top with Ron Sims. He lacks the brains that it takes to develop a decent transportation system. You can give this cute little bus system a fancy name like rapid ride, but the fact of the matter is it will still get stuck in traffic. What happens when signal pre-empts don’t work due to wrecks or blocked intersections? What will his excuse be then? I am sick of him trying to play like he is so forward thinking in transit. Blahh, move on buddy! I say we let Patty Murray have a say in who the new executive will be I am sure she knows someone!
I don’t think it’s a problem of brains with Ron Sims. I think he’s
– focused on a legacy that he can call his own, which is not Sound Transit
– chosen quick and cheap over good.
I partially agree and disagree. I think that there are a tons of things that metro could do to improve the quality of their service from a capital investment side (i.e. better facilities, better information system, bus lanes, new busses aka 49, etc). Metro is and always has been a capital frugal transit provider and I think that needs to change.
However I also think that metro is the only transit provider that can without doubt claim that its single priority should be more service hours. In the last day half of the buses I have rode were absolutely packed. If people can’t even get onto your buses you need to prioritize. CT and ST aren’t in the same situation on most routes.
Give a choice but fancy busses or more service I think that more service is a better choice especially if that bring service towards the 10 min headway level.
I also have to say that I’m sick and tired of people slamming BRT. Yes BRT is not the same thing as LRT but that doesn’t have to be a bad thing. BRT has different operating characteristics and is located on a continuum between express bus and LRT. I don’t think it should be used as a replacement to LRT but I think there are situation when it is a great solution.
One example is bus lanes. BRT should ideally be in its own ROW all the time but what if that entails destroying 10 buildings and buy millions of dollars of property? If there isn’t reoccurring congestion along that stretch of road it might not be worth it to add a bus lane. Also BRT service can help create a transit network based off of transfers that works much better than standard bus service.
These issue are more than can be discussed here but my point is simply don’t just disregard BRT just because it isn’t LRT. Also engineers aren’t stupid but they have constraints that are often overlooked in such simple overviews.
Adam,
The purpose of this post is not to slam BRT in general (except to say that it’s inferior to LRT) but to point out that this incarnation of it is barely worth the name.
The improvements over regular bus service in this case are trivial, and the resources are significant enough to have made a big difference in a transformative project like getting to Northgate.
Okay I see what you’re saying.
My solution: Give buses sirens, and let them run red lights and drive the wrong way when possible. Like ambulances.
A lot of this is kind of funny because the bus has always been the interim step between transit and no transit. Bus lovers talk about how the bus can flexibly switch routes, but in reality nobody ever said “Hey! Look over there! A bunch of underserved poor people who can’t afford cars want to ride the bus!” Hell, for most of my lifetime Seattle didn’t even pave the streets south of Dearborn.
When you build the amenities to make bus transit rapid, well, you might as well lay some rails and hang some wire, because, DUH!, what makes rail work is exactly the same thing that makes a bus work. Who knew.
In our world, though, all the things that might make a bus fast are touted as pricey and expendable extras, stuff you might build a little bit of if there was some agency requiring your advertising to be honest. As there is in fact no such agency, enjoy the color brochure, because that’s as good as it is ever going to get.
“I think that there are a tons of things that metro could do to improve the quality of their service from a capital investment side (i.e. better facilities, better information system, bus lanes, new busses aka 49, etc).”
Adam: you forgot to mention BETTER ROADS which will never happen.
One of the primary reasons potential transit users choose their cars over buses is directly related to the quality of ride. In a city and region where the majority of roadbed is cracked, potholed, and uneven (with little hope in sight for upgrade) it doesn’t matter how pretty they paint the buses: the ride will always suck.
Add on the fact each bus driver has his/her own unique method of driving (and often enters into a fit of speeding and braking when behind schedule because of auto-generated congestion, which the driver cannot control) the comfort level is unreliable at best.
To make things even worse, those heavy hybrid coaches make a large contribution to poor roadbed conditions – and you have what we call “a vicious cycle.”
“My solution: Give buses sirens, and let them run red lights”
Uhh…we already have buses frequently running red lights, particularly in Seattle.
“Adam: you forgot to mention BETTER ROADS which will never happen.”
I agree but just keep in mind that buses are the single largest cause of damage to roads, especially if you look at arterials that have heavy bus traffic. 15th Ave NE in the U-district is a great example.
Just one last note. I forgot the exact number (I went to the open house for the southend line a while back) but over ~60% of the cost of rapid ride is new buses. This means that metro can redeploy the buses that they currently use on the route. Either way metro was going to buy new buses to expand service so this kind of kills two birds with one stone.
I went to the Rapid Ride open house for West Seattle residents. Here’s what they are saying, at least what the gentleman I spoke with said: 1) The proposed RR route will replace the regular 54 route and follow the route as it exists now – using Avalon heading both east and west (no more bridge ride up the hill) 2) There is only ONE stop proposed between Alaska & Morgan Jct at Findlay 3) Apparently, the 54x will remain as is 4) They were ’surprised’ to hear everyone complaining about the 21 route – this route will not even be reviewed by Metro until at least 2010 or 2011 – a travesty in my opinion 5) the curb bulbs will not jut into the street, but take as much space as a parked car so should not interfere with traffic or bicycles 6) bus only lanes are being studied for both directions of Alaska between Fauntleroy and Alaska Jct. 7) the removal of the Viaduct and Spokane St construction will not even be discussed, this is like spraying insecticide into a jar of bugs – he ran away when it was mentioned These people do not understand how bad traffic gets or how mass transit is used/needed by West Seattlites. 9) Connection to the 21 may be lost if the 35th/Avalon stop is not utilized 10) The route could go all the way to Westwood Village – as planned now, it starts at the ferry dock. Get out there and give them feedback now! Metro seems set on this route and from what I understand, it’s not rapid, it reduces service, could make you use more transfers, may not connect with the 21 route, and the funds to be expended on this RR could be better used to expand existing service and routes. credmond, can you please direct me to a link of the tax we voted for? I would not mind adding routes that made sense, but replacing an already existing route with one that makes no sense is not a responsible choice. I don’t think anyone would have voted for that. Improving bus service in general is a whole different ball of wax and something we can agree on.