Why are there no freeways in Vancouver? (Undercouver)
This is an open thread.
82 Replies to “Sunday Movie: Why Are There No Freeways in Vancouver?”
Sometimes I wonder if i90 seattle-factoria would’ve been built had Forward Thrust been approved. In the end I think it would’ve been built but maybe with just 1 floating bridge and a smaller interchange footprint.
Similarly I doubt Vancouver would have as fantastic of a rapid transit system had they built those freeways.
In general I’ve noticed that BC cities are much more freeway averse than other parts of Canada/US. If you look at a map of Victoria, Kelowna, Kamloops, Nanaimo they don’t have downtown freeways. They sometimes have a road that’s technically designed as a highway but the infrastructure is really just a 4-6 lane road/boulevard.
Designated* as a highway not designed
Highway 97 through Kelowna and West Kelowna is a 20+ km strip mall. Not exactly pleasant. And it not being a limited access highway has more to do with geography and population than deliberate urban design, I think.
They replaced a three lane bridge with a reversible middle lane (the only way across the lake and a major choke point) with a five lane bridge, two lanes inbound and three lanes outbound fixed with no bus lane or bus priority a couple decades ago, so inbound rush hour went from two lanes with no transit priority to two lanes with no transit priority. There is a “BRT” bus along highway 97 with no priority except a completely unenforced HOV/transit/right turn lane for part of the route which is no faster than the regular travel lanes. I commute along that route sometimes by bus sometimes driving, but it’s 53 minutes by bus versus 30-40 driving. So don’t hold Kelowna up as any ideal of public transit or road design.
It’s a 50kmph stroad with sidewalks and traffic lights. Still a different class of road than a freeway like the ones we have in DT seattle or i90 in Spokane or Yakima.
I never said anything about it being ideal urban design. Just saying it’s not nearly as terrible as what I’ve observed in US and Ontario + Quebec
Uh, I drive it most days. It’s a 50 km/h road for a short stretch, and no one goes 50 km/h through there anyway: either it’s stop and go (afternoon rush) or it’s 70-plus km/h. Otherwise the speed limit is 60 for a bit but mostly 80. And I didn’t say it’s anything like a freeway; I’d said it’s a strip mall (a different kind of unpleasant). And it is definitely not pleasant for pedestrians, though it does have sidewalks and two quite well done pedestrian overpasses.
Seattle is 20 times the population of the Kelowna area, Spokane close to 4 times. Yakima is comparable but more because it’s along I-82, a through route. Wenatchee is a good comparison, and it doesn’t have a freeway. Kelowna isn’t along the major through route from Vancouver to the rest of Canada. So though I appreciate that Kelowna doesn’t have a major freeway through it, I’m not sure I’d give the city props for that. I’ve heard that it has the most pickup trucks per capita of any city in North America, and I believe it. It’s stunning how many fewer pickup trucks there are when I go to a nice city like Vancouver, Seattle, Toronto, or Boston.
The Mercer Island Bridge was built in the 1940s as part of US highway 10. I-90 merely renumbered it, until the last phase of the I-90 project in the 1980s that replaced the bridge. Forward Thrust was proposed in 1968 and 1970, after the bridge and the Mercer Slough viaduct were built and Factoria was a small shopping center.
King County’s growth plans in the 1970s and 80s intended to channel growth to the Eastside, and the I-90 corridor to Issaquah was going to be a star player alongside downtown Bellevue and Redmond. So Forward Thrust had a line on I-90 to Issaquah. There would have been a Y shape, with one line going northeast like East Link to Redmond, and the other going straight east to Factoria, Eastgate, and Issaquah.
But for some reason urban growth stagnated in the I-90 corridor. Downtown Bellevue got its highrises and condos, Redmond got Microsoft and later a downtown, but Factoria and Eastgate just got a few tower-in-the-park office parks and Factoria got a few more big-box stores, and Issaquah remained a small town until the 1990s. (The Issaquah Highlands opened in 1998, and the big-box stores and headquarters and industrial near Gilman Blvd are from that era too.) I don’t know why that happened. Factoria and Eastgate are still defined as regional growth centers, so they may become more like downtown Bellevue any decade now.
“The Mercer Island Bridge was built in the 1940s as part of US highway 10.”
This is a challenge in a “what if” scenario discussion. The bridge long pre-dates the Interstate system creation, but it’s been expanded over the decades. Keep in mind that Link took what was car lanes too.
That said, it really is more of what Bellevue allowed to be built there. I-90 did not enable Factoria all by itself. Consider that those buildings and shopping could have just as easily been built on Mercer Island or at Eastgate. It’s just that the real estate market and land availability in the height of the suburban era made its creation financially viable — in addition to the land use concepts at the time..
I don’t think I-90 being 4 lanes per direction is the reason why Seattle is congested and some part of Puget Sound is car-oriented. Many Chinese aren’t short of this kind of wide arterials or urban expressways viaducts.
It is all about timing. Vancouver doesn’t have much freeway infrastructure inside the city because a lot of the plans started in the mid-1960s. By then people were second-guessing freeways. People were willing to protest against them. In contrast, the Ship Canal (freeway) bridge was approved in 1958 and completed by 1962. The Evergreen Floating Bridge (520) opened about a year later. Expansion soon followed as it ate up Seattle, bit by bit.
In contrast, the R.H. Thomson Expressway was originally approved by voters in 1960. But court cases delayed it. By the end of the decade it was so unpopular that the city council didn’t want to spend money even studying it. That is how we ended up with “ramps to nowhere” in Montlake.
Forward Thrust didn’t come along until 1968. By then the tide had turned against most freeways (except for West Seattle) but the damage was done. Lawsuits delayed some of the work for I-90 though. It is possible that Forward Thrust would have influenced I-90 but I doubt it. It is also not as big of an issue. I-90 has a relatively small presence in Seattle compared to I-5. It would also be significantly smaller without I-5 (there would be no reason to extend it west of Rainier Avenue). These two interstates weren’t always connected but I have to assume that at some point they would have been. The big problem in Seattle is I-5 and that happened a bit too early to stop.
The geography between Vancouver and Seattle is surprisingly similar but there are subtle differences. To be clear, Vancouver most definitely has freeways. This (https://maps.app.goo.gl/sY6YyTQbgADKW2Yt7) is a freeway and it is within the city limits (let alone the metro area). But it basically skirts Vancouver proper (unlike in Seattle, where they just rammed it through the heart of the city). I see a couple reasons for this. Canada runs east-west. The Trans-Canada Highway manages to skirt the main urban area while also providing another crossing (to go along with the Lions Gate Bridge Bridge). This means that Abbotsford, Surrey, Burnaby, Vancouver, North Vancouver and West Vancouver are all connected via a freeway. It may not go through the heart of each city but it connects them. In contrast, if you want to go from an American city (like Bellingham) to Vancouver (or North/West Vancouver) you will spend a lot of time on something other than a freeway.
It is hard to imagine they would do that in Seattle. There was great interest in connecting cities like Tacoma and Everett (just like there was in connecting Abbotsford, Surrey, Burnaby, etc. in B.C.). Unlike Vancouver though, there was no easy way to skirt the city. The closest analogy would be to bypass the city entirely. I-5 would use the current 405. I-90 (as a freeway) would end at Rainier Valley. 520 would end at Montlake. You could have parts of the existing I-5 extending into the city from the north and south but they wouldn’t go north of Jackson or south of the ship canal.
This means that you aren’t really skirting the city — you are bypassing it entirely. Of course the elephant in the room is SR-99. They could have easily just made it the main freeway through town. While not up to current standards, it is basically a freeway from Green Lake to South Lake Union and a full-fledged freeway south of there. You would need to do the most work north of Green Lake. While a freeway on Aurora sounds horrible to urbanists (like me) it would be the I-5, leaving the existing pathway of I-5 (in Seattle) with normal surface streets. There would probably be more lanes along with safer (but uglier) ramps on Aurora. I-90 would probably still be connected to I-5 (most likely with viaducts) but 520 would probably just end at Montlake. Some urban planners would propose connecting 520 and I-5 but it would likely come too late in the decade. Likewise, some would suggest a second freeway but it wouldn’t happen (just as the Thomson expressway didn’t happen). We would have only one north-south freeway through downtown instead of two (and it would most likely be tunneled). With less to maintain there would likely be pressure to cap it to the north as well, at least as far as Green Lake. I think this is the most realistic of the “dream” scenarios.
Throughout most of the 20th century, freeways in the U.S. were seen as modernizing transportation for the future, while all other forms of transportation, including buses, streetcars, even walking, were viewed as legacy transportation systems, not worth investing in. Only after the freeways we’re built did the downsides of them start to become clear, but by then, it was too late.
I did not watch the video, but I’m guessing that Vancouver was late enough to the freeway game that they could see from many U.S. examples that running a freeway right to downtown is not good for the city, so they wanted to do things differently. They probably also had a less powerful freeway construction lobby.
Freeways were also used to facilitate “blight abatement” aka removal of communities of people of color while plowing connections straight to central business districts. Most countries outside the USA built “ring roads” around their downtown cores.
I think what’s interesting about Vancouver is how it doesn’t even have a ring road, and there are no major grade-separated freeways anywhere near its core.
TLDR; In the 1960s there were freeway proposals AND FREEWAY REVOLTS across North America. The revolt in Vancouver succeeded. The route would have gone through the middle of Chinatown and Gastown, which were then lower-income nonwhite neighborhoods. The public protested and got it canceled.
Only a tenth of the proposed freeways in the US were built, so the insanity went only so far. In Seattle, the Bay Freeway (Mercer Street area) would have connected a 99 freeway upgrade, I-5, and the proposed Thompson freeway on MLK. 15th Ave W was built as an expressway, and would probably have been upgraded or at least made more of an expressway too.
Do you guys have any idea how awful it was in cities when they were blighted by steam trains and horses? I remember talking to my grandma as a teenager and lamenting cars. She very quickly set me straight. Living anywhere near a train line was an awful, and probably cancerous experience, and the waste from horses made the rest very smelly. Then there was the terror of polio…
Because living near a freeway today isn’t an awful, cancerous, loud and smelly experience?
OK, but upgrading a street or boulevard or neighborhood to a freeway is making things much worse. Freeway/expressway cars go faster, use more fuel, spew more emissions, and induced demand generates more trips. The switch from “dirty” horses to “clean” cars was a half century before freeways, and the cars could only go 30 mph. In the 1920s only 10% of Seattlites had cars, and in the 1950s it was rare to have more than one car per family. So there were fewer cars around then. Their limited number and speed may have caused them to have less of an impact they did later, and to be seen as relatively more environmental than horses. That era was long gone by the time freeways began to be built.
In one article I ran across some years ago, it was stated that if the Portland area Mt Hood Freeway and interchanges were built, it would have taken out some 10% of Portland’s housing.
Sure, there were good reasons to replace horses with automobiles.
That doesn’t mean too many automobiles are a good thing, or don’t come with extensive societal costs.
DM, do some research. There’s no way that today’s auto pollution comes close to what it was in my childhood. Leaded gas and no emission controls until around 1970. And that was still way better than coal dust and smoke from coal fires. Not to mention the continuous clang and roar from switching yards. For most of the industrial era cities were places people fled from as soon as they made enough money. About 100 years ago ancestors of mine bought land 60 miles south of NYC, near the end of the then new commuter railroad, as soon as they had money to escape. Other relatives operated a farm in the Castskills, and made it thru the depression boarding children of city families all summer. Their parents were desperate to get them away from the Polio virus. Cities as pleasant, habitable places that you lived in by choice is a very new phenomenon, and still only true in the developed world.
BTW, I don’t know about Seattle in the 60s, but in the northeastern city I lived in, there was ZERO demand for lakefront properties – the smell made it highly undesirable. And of course there was always the risk of the lake catching fire.
The incidence of childhood cancer in the nation has been increasing since 1975, the report says. The most common form of childhood cancer is leukemia, representing about one-third of all cancers among children 14 and younger. The cause is unknown for about 90% of childhood leukemia cases.”
The review found that children diagnosed with leukemia were “50% more likely to live near busy roads than children without leukemia,” said Vickie Boothe, a CDC health scientist and lead author of the Journal article. “While the study found a link, it does not prove that living near a busy road causes leukemia.”
Sure, correlation does not equal causation and conditions are certainly better than they were, but it still isn’t good.
The origin of Metro was to create a county wide sewer district; mainly to clean up Lake Washington where most of the homes were dumping raw sewerage into the lake. It was actually a combined sewer and transportation agency for quite some time. When Seattle Transit was on the verge of collapse “Metro” was the only County wide agency that could tax and spend on a regional basis. And the agreement lead to years of empty buses being added to the eastside to “pay back” the money to bail out Seattle Transit (largely their pension fund). Back then virtually every bus ran from “somewhere” on the eastside to DT Seattle. It was a “star” or “hub & spoke” system so pretty much only useful if you were commuting. So of course mid-day buses were mostly empty. And of course this coincided with auto ownership becoming ubiquitous. Even HS kids had cars or had a friend that had a car (everything creeps up from CA). That was the switch from one car per household to two or more cars. And since bus service was mostly useless that’s how the eastside developed.
Living near a busy road increases a person’s chance of developing lung cancer by 10% and
Cars pollute far less from the tailpipe than they did prior to the 80s & 90s when fuel injection and computers took over engine management. But a nasty source of pollution from cars remains brake dust and particles from tire wear. There’s been links to goal keepers in soccer having health issues from the synthetic “turf” fields which are almost always a fake grass mat with a bed of ground up tires. Brakes don’t have asbestos in them anymore but the fine dust particles still aren’t good. And then there’s the oil and other fluids that leach into the environment. Don’t think that’s much; watch how many spin out accidents there are after the first rain following a dry stretch. And the shear number of cars/traffic has grown substantially since the 70’s. EVs still have the brake dust and tire wear pollution. And that’s not to mention the incremental demand for electricity is primarily carbon based. At least it’s nat-gas instead of coal which is better used to run turbines and generate electricity vs flaring it off at the well like most of it now. Look at a night sky image today and the Dakota’s look like a major metropolitan area because of all the oil rigs burning of the excess
gas.
Only after the freeways we’re built did the downsides of them start to become clear, but by then, it was too late.
It was more than that. From the very beginning they were controversial. Thus if Ike — often referred to as the “father of the American Interstate System” — had his way, they would look a lot like what they do in Vancouver. Keep in mind, this still isn’t great but it is a lot nicer than what is typically found in North America. There is just a lot less damage to the neighborhood. It also makes them less attractive as a means of transportation and in turn quite likely leads to less sprawl* .
There was a change in attitude but this had more to do with sensibilities. The same thing could be said about the Vietnam war** (as the video pointed out). This was the era of questioning authority and post-war assumptions. This included the war, civil rights and women’s liberation but also the environment and city planning. So while some might have opposed large-scale freeways in the city from the get-go, by the end of the decade they were willing to protest (and take other actions) to stop it.
*For example, SeaBus can compete with driving to Downtown Vancouver (for some trips). That is because once you get to Vancouver via the Lions Gate Bridge (on what is essentially a freeway) you have to slog your way on surface streets. As I write this it takes about ten minutes just to go a ways on the surface highway. In contrast, a similar trip on I-5 takes three minutes.
**In the 1950s there wasn’t much opposition to our involvement in Vietnam but by the late 60s there was a lot. To be clear a lot of this had to do with the fact that so many Americans were dying but it was also clear (to a lot of people) that our involvement was making things worse in Vietnam (and eventually the surrounding area).
Also Canada doesn’t really have a freeway system that connects across different province well enough. Some of the US cities has tons of long distance through traffic cutting near its suburbs like I-294 in Chicago and I-285 in Atlanta. Both have very high truck percentages for urban freeway.
EU has a better freeway network but they also have better alternatives for intercity passengers to avoid highway.
China has a similar national turnpike system to US Interstate’s scale, but driving long distance is more expensive because of gas price and distance-based toll rate similar to Pennsylvania turnpike.
Today Community Transit officially turns 50. From leasing school buses to connecting buses to light rail is crazy to think about.
It makes sense for an area transitioning from rural. School buses were what they had.
Yeah, and Community Transit has never been bigger than ever. I love the evolution.
Webmaster, check your email. There is a page two submission sitting there.
I haven’t seen this email. I’m checking with the other editors. What address did you send it to? You have a WordPress account, so you can create the article yourself. Then if you don’t have permission to publish it, press the review button to request a review.
Michael Smith found an email September 13th he thinks is it. I didn’t receive it, so I can’t do anything until somebody forwards it. In the meantime, it’s easiest for us if you enter the article into WordPress yourself, since that’s what we’d do.
Metro has released their latest restructure plan, and here’s what they plan to do:
With Stride S1 right around the corner and the new Renton TC opening, Metro is looking into ways to complement these changes and better serve the people in the area. Here are the ideas they came up with for the first phase:
– Redirect all current Renton TC bus routes to the new transit center (except for the 101, F Line, and future I Line.
– Change the overlapping part of the Metro FLEX areas of Renton Highlands and Bryn Mawr-Skyway to the new Renton TC rather than the current one.
– All current 102 trips that end at South Renton P&R (future Renton TC) would become 101 trips.
– The 101, F Line, and I Line (currently the 160) would not go into the current Renton TC, but stop outside of it.
– The F Line no longer uses 16th/Lind/7th to Rainier Ave from Oaksdale , it would instead use Oaksdale/Grady to Rainier Ave (stopping at the new Renton TC).
– The 143 is formally deleted.
With these changes, the growing Black Diamond community loses their opportunity to keep their one-seat ride to Seattle, the F Line, I Line, and the 101 still stop in the vicinity of Renton TC for some reason (Metro will likely refer to this area as “Downtown Renton” like how the 532/535 continue from Bellevue TC into Downtown Bellevue), and 16th loses their bus service.
Aside from that, I wholeheartedly support these changes. The F Line could become more direct, service could be somewhat simplified with the 102 trips to South Renton P&R (aka future Renton TC) becoming 101 trips (despite travel time added due to the Downtown Renton routing), and we straight up delete the 143 that surprisingly wasn’t deleted in Fall 2026 along with all the other suspended South King routes (that and the 186).
Metro needs to interline the 105 with the 101, 106, or 107 so that people can go somewhere further than downtown Renton without a half-hour transfer wait. It’s in Metro Connects but it’s not in this proposal.
“Service levels would remain the same on all other Metro routes in Renton” besides the 102 and 907. So the 105 won’t even get a frequency boost to mitigate its orphan routing. That’s understandable because it’s a revenue-neutral restructure, but the point is the restructure still doesn’t meet Renton’s mobility needs.
“the growing Black Diamond community loses their opportunity to keep their one-seat ride to Seattle”
Even after growing, it’s still probably small, exurban, and car-oriented. Is there more than a few unwalkable big-box stores and strip malls? I would be extremely surprised if it has sprouted something like downtown Everett. So why should an exurban community on the far side of Renton have a peak express to Seattle? They can go to Renton and transfer, or use the proposed-expanded 907 (that was expanded partly to mitigate the loss of the express, and to support more off-peak trips since that’s the direction ridership is going.
“Metro needs to interline the 105 with the 101, 106, or 107 so that people can go somewhere further than downtown Renton without a half-hour transfer wait.”
Yes twin, I’ve mused having a bus route from Renton Highlands to Downtown Seattle via the 101 path but then takes the 105/111 path. Such a route would have made a decent replacement for the 111 (which just got truncated at South Bellevue Station). Renton Highlands is underrated and needs better bus service.
“So why should an exurban community on the far side of Renton have a peak express to Seattle?”
It’s historically been tied to Seattle via rail, but ideally every city like Black Diamond (e.g: Orting, DuPont) should have a connection to Seattle or close enough (like a Link or Sounder connection).
“They can go to Renton and transfer, or use the proposed-expanded 907”
But there’s not a lot of good connections at Renton TC. The service to Seattle is basically just an express and that’s it. In order to justify a transfer it needs to be something like Link or Sounder. I understand what you’re trying to say but there needs to be at least more service on the 907 corridor or a better connection at Renton.
Part of the problem with transit to Black Diamond (and Maple Valley, etc.) is that the road doesn’t have HOV lanes. Thus the bus is stuck in the same traffic as cars. It might offer a more comfortable trip, but not a faster one. This in turn limits the popularity and cost-effectiveness of the route, especially during peak. Throw in working from home (which is bound to impact trips from Black Diamond a lot more than it would trips from say, Ballard) and I can see why the 907 is sufficient to handle demand.
This is a general problem. Worse yet, we add lanes that are not HOV. This was the case with SR-522 to Monroe. They added lanes but regular lanes (not HOV). The HOV lanes don’t start until Bothell. This in turn makes peak-only service less attractive. At the same time, there isn’t enough demand to support all-day service, especially since it is expensive to go all the way to Monroe. Thus they are stuck in this nasty in-between state: enough demand to cause major traffic jams but not enough to support decent transit.
It is a classic example of how screwed up zoning is in America — we allow sprawl but restrict urban development. Then we struggle to pay for the road infrastructure that would enable people to get from one place to another without sitting in a huge traffic jam. Worse yet, we add lanes that are not HOV. This was the case with 522 to Monroe. They added lanes but regular lanes (not HOV). (The HOV lanes don’t start until Bothell.)
Surprised that they decided to send F to SW Grady Way. I thought F is like what it is today to avoid SW Grady Way traffic. Renton is making SW 7th an active transportation corridor and is putting multi-use path there. Isn’t it a better street to run bus?
Pinehurst station has its first elevator outage.
And so did Star Lake on the first day of service.
Central Link’s opening was delayed simply because Sound Transit needed to work a little more on Beacon Hill’s elevators (since it was the only way to enter the station).
Imo there needs to be elevator testing as much as how there’s simulated service testing for the trains and station stops.
What a cool video!! I haven’t heard of this creator before but I enjoy his style. One of my favorite things about Vancouver is there are no freeways in the city proper, except of course, the Trans-Canada Highway on the very eastern edge. I’m so glad the freeway revolts of the 1960s succeeded there.
Yeah, I enjoyed it as well. He is witty and provided just enough information to make it worth watching.
I could have done without the drug/psychedelic stunts, but the video addressed an issue that’s directly relevant to us and everyone has overlooked: Vancouver doesn’t have freeways except in its periphery, but why not? Was there a decision to do that?
Northbound Link train is/was stuck at IDC Station, trains being turned back, bus bridges being called up. This was as of a few minutes ago. All of this may have changed by now.
Turnbacks at Judkins, Westlake, and Stadium.
Seems to be clearing up. Blocking train cleared.
Link was running fine for me at 8:15 pm. I boarded at SeaTac after flying back today.
Is the lack of comments about Pinehurst Station since its opening a sign that its importance to North Seattle was overstated?
I think it says more about the overall fraction of people in Puget Sound that participate in this website.
Overstated by who? I’ve just been wondering how this gets built before Graham. Maybe Seattle didn’t want to give up least productive station honors to Least Main in Bellevue?
Sam, I visited Pinehurst Station this weekend. I missed the opening since it happened during the work week. Interestingly, there weren’t very many people using the brand new station on a sunny afternoon, especially with all the events going on in the city. As I was wrapping up my self-guided station tour I saw the new bus 77 coming westbound. I decided to check it out. I rode it through Lake City, the Roosevelt District and got off in the U District. After all the recent Link openings, Pinehurst felt very underwhelming but the 77 was kind of cool.
I’m sure there aren’t a lot of comments because the station is boring. This is a good thing. In contrast, Northgate is quite complicated. To be fair, it has a lot going on. The mezzanine is justified given the bridge to the college. The direct walkway to the mall/parking lot is valuable (I guess). But I still find it confusing and have gone down the wrong way more than once.
In contrast the Pinehurst Station is quite simple. It should have been a lot cheaper to build (although it wasn’t that expensive compared to the rest of Lynnwood Link). It has two platforms but it is quite obvious which one you go up, since you are outside. (In contrast I think I’ve gone down the wrong set of stairs at more than one downtown station.)
The more interesting thing is the connection with the buses and the other changes on the surface. This is a work in progress. They are still doing a lot of work on the road. They will widen the pathway to the west. Eventually the city council will get around to rezoning the area and then we’ll see a bunch of new apartments/condos. Likewise, there is always hope that Metro will provide something better than the obviously flawed 77 in the future (is there a bat-signal for Jarrett Walker?).
It is also an infill station. If Lynnwood Link did not include any other station then I’m sure it would have a similar response. Even some of the existing stations that are part of extensions haven’t gotten many comments. People go to the grand opening, maybe check out a few stations and then go about their business. But this lack of comments doesn’t mean initial low ridership, let alone low ridership in the long run. I don’t know if I’ve ever read about anyone using say, Star Lake Station but it got over 1,500 riders the last three months. I would expect ridership to start out slow at the station and then build as people realize it is a good option (even with the flawed Metro routing).
The bigger question that I think needs to be asked is what happens after HB 1491 is in effect for a decade or two.
HB 1491 is the mandated transit oriented development law that requires a higher FAR and forgives parking minimums within a half-mile of a station.
However, so much of the half mile radius of Pinehurst Station is taken by I-5 or Jackson Park Golf Course. So its impact seems more muted than at other Link stations.
I am one of those who expect low ridership at the station. Others are more optimistic. We should know after a few months of operation. And how Metro riders use Route 77 will take several months before that info is available.
However, so much of the half mile radius of Pinehurst Station is taken by I-5 or Jackson Park Golf Course. So its impact seems more muted than at other Link stations.
Yes, but that is true of every station in Lynnwood Link as well as many other stations. I still find it odd that people say things about Pinehurst Station while ignoring the fact that it is true of other stations. The only reason people focus on Pinehurst is because it was not included initially.
I’m sure the same thing would happen with any other station (other than Lynnwood). If we have Pinehurst and 185th do we really need a station at South Shoreline given that (in your words) so much of the half mile radius of Pinehurst Station is taken by I-5 or Jackson Park Golf Course. What if we had every station but Mountlake Terrace. Then it becomes “so much of the half mile radius of Pinehurst Station is taken by I-5 or Nile Shrine Golf Course”. Only Mountlake Terrace doesn’t have a golf course — instead those words can be replaced with “green belt”. Oh, and even Lynnwood Station has that. Again, none of the stations within Lynnwood Link have good development potential. Zero. Zilch. All of them require bus feeders and (to a certain degree) large parking lots. But if we ignore the former do we really need so much of the latter? Remember, Northgate has an enormous amount of parking. If we assume that every station is highly dependent on parking then why build so many? If bus integration doesn’t matter, if building an obviously better bus network doesn’t matter, if the the only thing that matters is walk-up potential and park and ride lots then maybe we shouldn’t have any stations between Lynnwood and Northgate. Just build bigger parking lots at each station and call it a day. You don’t save that much money (these are above ground stations after all) but you still save some.
That is absurd, of course. Bus integration does matter. A better bus network does matter. However limited, the walk-up ridership adds up. Pinehurst Station (just like both Shoreline stations and the one in Mountlake Station) are definitely worth it, assuming the cost of building Lynnwood Link (most of which is for the line itself) is worth it.
There were hardly any comments at all between Friday and Sunday. I almost told the commentariat it was below quota and not up to Sam’s standards. But you got to it first.
I’ve tried to go up there a few times but plans kept falling through. On opening day I went north to the station at 5:30pm, intending to see the station area and ride the 77, but I also needed to get to Costco for something my relative needed urgently, and I had my work equipment in my backpack. So in the end I looked down from the train but didn’t get off, and continued to Shoreline North. I was hoping to get Swift Blue in its 10-minute daytime frequency, but I got there and it was a 9 minute wait, and I decided it wasn’t worth it to do that transfer and have a longer walk to get to a location that has the products in less familiar and less convenient locations, so I turned around and, would you believe it, went to the SODO Costco.
I haven’t had a reason to go to Lake City since Wednesday, and with Fred Meyer and Value Village gone, that’s two fewer reasons. I’ll get there sometime. My support for the station is primarily for residents of Lake City and Bitter Lake and Pinehurst, and would-be future residents and shoppers. Those are a lot more numerous than just me.
“HB 1491 is the mandated transit oriented development law that requires a higher FAR and forgives parking minimums within a half-mile of a station.”
The city wanted Pinehurst station in 2016 and said it would upzone the station area. It procrastinated on the upzone for years but finally did something. I think it wants to do more now but it’s being held up for a citywide environmental review to justify Wilson’s citywide upzones. So the city council procrastinated 5-7 years longer than it should have, but the station area is getting upzoned, regardless of the state mandate.
So the state mandate wasn’t necessary for Pinehurst’s case, and I doubt it requires more than the city did anyway. It may even require less.
It procrastinated on the upzone for years but finally did something.
Did it though? I thought they still haven’t approved the changes. According to this map it is still neighborhood residential.
Oh, and according to that map, so is the area (within Seattle) close to the 148th Station. That station has been there for years now and still they haven’t passed the upzone. The closest area with an upzone is close to 15th & 145 (which has seen some recent new development). Seattle has been dragging its feet when it comes to Lynnwood Link while Shoreline actually made some changes.
Look like MR2, 8 stories. Though might still be in the courts.
Yeah, I know the proposal (they talked about it for years). I just didn’t know if it was ever actually signed into law.
EIS appeals. Per the website:
“Council began review of this legislation in April but put their work on hold in July due to an ongoing appeal of environmental analysis. We anticipate that Council will restart their review of the legislation in early 2027.”
Does KCM have a hotspot map of where to most amount of delays occurs? I would be really useful as we could see visually where bus improvements are needed instead of an anecdotal “oh the 372 gets delayed at the intersection of x and y for 5 minutes everyday”
In theory, this could be created with GPS location pings on phones. The problem is figuring out the cause. Is the bus stopped more often because of a signal that’s ill-timed, becatt urea of a bus merge that is difficult or because it has a higher share of wheelchair riders that use a stop? So it’s more useful as a screening tool but not in assigning a specific automatic solution.
It should also be feasible to do this with Metro’s live bus tracking data. They certainly do this analysis internally when determining where to do bus improvements, but I haven’t seen a system-wide map.
It’d probably have to be personal/unofficial project.
A while back “lurker: referenced this document with a priority list by corridor (not route). They only considered routes that they aren’t planning on improving (as part of the last transportation levy). They ranked projects based on congestion as well as the number of riders impacted by it. The latter was based on the total ridership of the routes that go along the corridor. This is a reasonable approach given congestion impacts everyone on the corridor directly and indirectly. Riders who are “down stream” of the congested area have to deal with delays which are not consistent. This in turn leads to irregular frequency and worse, bus bunching. Even if this isn’t a problem it impacts the cost of the trip, which impacts everyone. The cost is based on frequency and trip time but the total ridership of the route influences frequency (high ridership routes tend to run more often). Thus this approach is good overall.
The only major flaw is that it assumes that routes don’t change. Consider 85th NW for example. It has been served by the 45 for years. But now the 61 also runs along the corridor, impacting those riders as well. Thus the impact of congestion along 85th has gone up. Except with the most recent change, the 45 is no longer paired with the 75. It just ends at the triangle. Thus ridership on that bus went down. Thus moves the needle up and down. Not only that, but very congested corridors are often avoided for this very reason. The C and D line are no longer paired because congestion (especially around the Ballard Bridge) made the pairing unreliable.
Yet despite this flaw I think it is a good metric. I think it makes sense as a starting point. The other big issue is how easy is to fix a congested area. There are parts of the 44 for example that can’t be easily fixed (where there are other parts that can). Sometimes it is best to get the low hanging fruit rather than worry about whether it is the sweetest.
[Note: I updated the comment as I found the previous comment and the document that was referenced]
Depending on your definition of delay. In traffic engineering world, vehicle delay is actual travel time minus free-flow travel time, but in transit performance measure, delay is how much the bus is behind schedule.
During busy hours, schedule is usually adjusted to make it easier for bus to arrive on time, so a 0 minute delay only means the scheduling team does an awesome job to predict the travel time. It doesn’t mean bus doesn’t get stuck in traffic and have room for travel time improvement.
Therefore, I don’t think transit improvement corridor identification is just about transit real-time data. I think in order to identify corridors for transit travel time improvement, they should also look at traffic corridor congestion level. The most congested corridor without transit priority should be the highest priority for transit priority treatment.
I think in order to identify corridors for transit travel time improvement, they should also look at traffic corridor congestion level.
That is basically what the report looked at (that I referenced in the previous comment).
Earlier this morning, I was looking for train tickets between New York and Philadelphia, with costs running at around $100-$150 per person, each on the Northeast regional line, or $200-$300 on the Acela. This on top of having to pay an additional $100/round trip for the privilege of carrying my dog.
It is insane how expensive train travel in the U.S. has become. How are you going to get people to take the train over driving when, even for people that do not have cars, a rental car is hundreds of dollars cheaper?
Rental cars have also become much more expensive, especially when you take into account all the local taxes and fees that politicians seem to think have no downside, because you are taxing non-voters, for the most part. And gas. Don’t forget gas.
As someone who rides the Cascades a fair amount and often struggle to book a last-minute (or a seat within a week or two, at peak times) trip to Eugene or either Vancouver, I suspect that they have room to raise Cascade prices. It clearly makes sense when I’m travelling alone. It’s when I’m bringing the family it starts to feel expensive.
Except the average cost to go from NYC to Philly by train is much lower than that.
It says if you book in advance, round trip tickets can be as low as $22 to $40. Last minute tickets are closer to your quotes. But, yes, Amtrak can get expensive. I think it’s interesting how it can sometimes be so much more costly than flying. So, I don’t think a lot of people balk at the train ticket price, then opt to drive. I think they opt to fly.
Rental car companies have started routinely sending us bills after we return the car, insisting on an extra $500 or so for imaginary damages detected by their AI scanner or something. At least it’s happened the last 2 times.
What rental agency? We’ve had good luck with Enterprise. We managed to rip the valance panel off the bumper while on a trip in Yellowstone. We threw it in the trunk and figured we would pay for it when we returned the car (and if it was really expensive we would have insurance pay for it). We mentioned it and they didn’t charge us anything. We have been using Enterprise a lot and maybe they cut us a break but even so, they were great.
Hertz.
Yeah, I’ve had good luck with Enterprise. Not using Hertz again.
The attempt to buy the train tickets was with about three weeks advance notice.
I should also note that the cheapest tickets all had departure times at very odd hours. If you wanted to not leave very early in the morning or arrive very late at night, it was starting at around $125 for regular service, $250 for Acela service. Multiply by 4 (2 adults, 2 directions), then add the $100 pet fee, it adds up fast. The $100 pet fee is also ridiculous, given that the pet is in a carrier and cannot leave hair or messes behind. It’s essentially them milking the customer, taking advantage of the fact that intercity buses generally disallow pets (except service animals) altogether, leaving rental cars as the only competition.
Anyway, going back to our trip, at the times we wanted, the grand total for two adults, plus one dog added up to $694, and would still require the person we were meeting to drive 30 minutes into downtown Philly to pick us up. With a rental car, we only needed one day, a the trip is a day trip. The total was around $88, after taxes and fees. The pickup is at Newark Airport, eliminating the traffic hassles of driving through NYC and the tunnels leaving in and out of it. Even adding another $34 (also very high) to take public transportation to the rental car facility, plus an unknown amount for electricity and tolls on the NJ Turnpike, we’re still saving over $500 compared to taking the train. And, we don’t need to ask the person to drive out of their way to pick us up and drop us off.
This should not be the case. But, it’s what happens when rail is priced to make a profit (the NE corridor does turn a profit, which subsidizes service on other routes), rather than serve the public.
Yeah, that’s a lot. The day trip aspect definitely makes it substantially more expensive compared to the rental.
And I agree with your larger point that our federal government should be subsidizing the infrastructure at least at the level that they subsidize highways, waterways, and airports, preferably more, given their differential environmental impacts.
That said, I’ve recently done similar distance several day-trips between Tacoma and Vancouver, and they have cost a fraction of that – under $100 round-trip for business class. I’m not sure why the differential. Does owning their own tracks make it MORE expensive?
Maybe Cascades passengers benefit (from ticket prices, not smooth, fast ride) from BNSF not bothering to maintain their tracks very well.
Does owning their own tracks make it MORE expensive? Maybe Cascades passengers benefit (from ticket prices, not smooth, fast ride) from BNSF not bothering to maintain their tracks very well.
The Northeast Corridor (which doesn’t receive state subsidies for operations) uses airline-style demand pricing. If the trains are close to full (or projected to be full by the pricing algorithm and the humans who supervise it), prices go up. I believe state-supported routes like Cascades in general don’t use demand pricing.
Cost has nothing directly to do with pricing when demand-based pricing is used; the trains are running with a more-or-less fixed number of seats and a predetermined schedule, and the goal is to maximize revenue within that constraint. That includes higher fares when the seats will sell anyway and lower fares to stimulate demand if not. Long term, if costs are lower than revenue (including subsidies), they can increase capacity to increase revenue and profit, but that isn’t cheap or easy. And vice versa: if revenue (including subsidies) is below costs, they can decrease capacity to reduce costs.
Cascades has been using demand pricing for a couple decades. But the state subsidy keeps prices lower than they’d otherwise be.
Washington state subsidizes Cascades.
I think Northeast Regional is a little bit pricey, but it is not ridiculously pricey.
Acela is definitely too expensive. The problem is that it is not even fast enough to be that pricey.
Acela’s popularity is largely made possible by scheduling the train at popular time. If there was always a NER departing Penn Station around the same time as Acela, Acela wouldn’t be nearly as unpopular as it is today.
There usually is a NER departing Penn Station around the same time as Acela. Often there will be a NER train departing just minutes before after Acela. This is more obvious at the beginning of the line (trains departing Washington nothbound), where for the most part Regional trains leave 5-15 minutes after an Acela train.
I generally agree; it’s fairly rare that I care about the time savings Acela offers enough to pay the fare difference (though sometimes the fares are comparable: on the random date I happen to be looking at, the 15:25-18:24 Acela is $62 and the 15:30-18:58 Regional $58, and the 16:02-19:24 Regional is more expensive ($82) than the 16:20-19:20 Acela ($62)). People use Acela anyway, so clearly some people see it as valuable. In the NE Corridor there’s enough supply so they can offer both alternatives, which is great. Acela profit subsidizes much of the rest of Amtrak.
Yeah, it is common to charge more for faster service in Europe as well. The difference is that in Europe the trains are faster at every level. They tend to be cheaper as well.
I don’t know about the Continent but they are not cheaper in the UK. When my cousin comes over from England he and his wife are amazed at how cheap the train and transit in general is to “back home”. They’ve also commented on how spacious the seating is. Of course the option to drive in England, especially around London, is much more expensive than here and a large percentage of the time slower. So it’s easier for them to charge more; especially when the trains are generally full.
What are train prices in other countries? Compared to:
A. A New York – Philadelphia type trip on a basic speed line.
B. A New York – Philadelphia type trip on a high speed line.
C. A DC-Boston type trip on a basic speed line. (Northeast corridor end-to-end.)
D. A DC-Boston type trip on a high speed line.
E. A Seattle-Portland type trip on a basic speed line.
F. A Seattle-Portland type trip on a high speed line.
G. A Seattle-Oakland (California) type trip on a basic speed line.
H. A Seattle-Oakland (California) type trip on a high speed line.
Sometimes I wonder if i90 seattle-factoria would’ve been built had Forward Thrust been approved. In the end I think it would’ve been built but maybe with just 1 floating bridge and a smaller interchange footprint.
Similarly I doubt Vancouver would have as fantastic of a rapid transit system had they built those freeways.
In general I’ve noticed that BC cities are much more freeway averse than other parts of Canada/US. If you look at a map of Victoria, Kelowna, Kamloops, Nanaimo they don’t have downtown freeways. They sometimes have a road that’s technically designed as a highway but the infrastructure is really just a 4-6 lane road/boulevard.
Designated* as a highway not designed
Highway 97 through Kelowna and West Kelowna is a 20+ km strip mall. Not exactly pleasant. And it not being a limited access highway has more to do with geography and population than deliberate urban design, I think.
They replaced a three lane bridge with a reversible middle lane (the only way across the lake and a major choke point) with a five lane bridge, two lanes inbound and three lanes outbound fixed with no bus lane or bus priority a couple decades ago, so inbound rush hour went from two lanes with no transit priority to two lanes with no transit priority. There is a “BRT” bus along highway 97 with no priority except a completely unenforced HOV/transit/right turn lane for part of the route which is no faster than the regular travel lanes. I commute along that route sometimes by bus sometimes driving, but it’s 53 minutes by bus versus 30-40 driving. So don’t hold Kelowna up as any ideal of public transit or road design.
It’s a 50kmph stroad with sidewalks and traffic lights. Still a different class of road than a freeway like the ones we have in DT seattle or i90 in Spokane or Yakima.
I never said anything about it being ideal urban design. Just saying it’s not nearly as terrible as what I’ve observed in US and Ontario + Quebec
Uh, I drive it most days. It’s a 50 km/h road for a short stretch, and no one goes 50 km/h through there anyway: either it’s stop and go (afternoon rush) or it’s 70-plus km/h. Otherwise the speed limit is 60 for a bit but mostly 80. And I didn’t say it’s anything like a freeway; I’d said it’s a strip mall (a different kind of unpleasant). And it is definitely not pleasant for pedestrians, though it does have sidewalks and two quite well done pedestrian overpasses.
Seattle is 20 times the population of the Kelowna area, Spokane close to 4 times. Yakima is comparable but more because it’s along I-82, a through route. Wenatchee is a good comparison, and it doesn’t have a freeway. Kelowna isn’t along the major through route from Vancouver to the rest of Canada. So though I appreciate that Kelowna doesn’t have a major freeway through it, I’m not sure I’d give the city props for that. I’ve heard that it has the most pickup trucks per capita of any city in North America, and I believe it. It’s stunning how many fewer pickup trucks there are when I go to a nice city like Vancouver, Seattle, Toronto, or Boston.
The Mercer Island Bridge was built in the 1940s as part of US highway 10. I-90 merely renumbered it, until the last phase of the I-90 project in the 1980s that replaced the bridge. Forward Thrust was proposed in 1968 and 1970, after the bridge and the Mercer Slough viaduct were built and Factoria was a small shopping center.
King County’s growth plans in the 1970s and 80s intended to channel growth to the Eastside, and the I-90 corridor to Issaquah was going to be a star player alongside downtown Bellevue and Redmond. So Forward Thrust had a line on I-90 to Issaquah. There would have been a Y shape, with one line going northeast like East Link to Redmond, and the other going straight east to Factoria, Eastgate, and Issaquah.
But for some reason urban growth stagnated in the I-90 corridor. Downtown Bellevue got its highrises and condos, Redmond got Microsoft and later a downtown, but Factoria and Eastgate just got a few tower-in-the-park office parks and Factoria got a few more big-box stores, and Issaquah remained a small town until the 1990s. (The Issaquah Highlands opened in 1998, and the big-box stores and headquarters and industrial near Gilman Blvd are from that era too.) I don’t know why that happened. Factoria and Eastgate are still defined as regional growth centers, so they may become more like downtown Bellevue any decade now.
“The Mercer Island Bridge was built in the 1940s as part of US highway 10.”
This is a challenge in a “what if” scenario discussion. The bridge long pre-dates the Interstate system creation, but it’s been expanded over the decades. Keep in mind that Link took what was car lanes too.
That said, it really is more of what Bellevue allowed to be built there. I-90 did not enable Factoria all by itself. Consider that those buildings and shopping could have just as easily been built on Mercer Island or at Eastgate. It’s just that the real estate market and land availability in the height of the suburban era made its creation financially viable — in addition to the land use concepts at the time..
I don’t think I-90 being 4 lanes per direction is the reason why Seattle is congested and some part of Puget Sound is car-oriented. Many Chinese aren’t short of this kind of wide arterials or urban expressways viaducts.
It is all about timing. Vancouver doesn’t have much freeway infrastructure inside the city because a lot of the plans started in the mid-1960s. By then people were second-guessing freeways. People were willing to protest against them. In contrast, the Ship Canal (freeway) bridge was approved in 1958 and completed by 1962. The Evergreen Floating Bridge (520) opened about a year later. Expansion soon followed as it ate up Seattle, bit by bit.
In contrast, the R.H. Thomson Expressway was originally approved by voters in 1960. But court cases delayed it. By the end of the decade it was so unpopular that the city council didn’t want to spend money even studying it. That is how we ended up with “ramps to nowhere” in Montlake.
Forward Thrust didn’t come along until 1968. By then the tide had turned against most freeways (except for West Seattle) but the damage was done. Lawsuits delayed some of the work for I-90 though. It is possible that Forward Thrust would have influenced I-90 but I doubt it. It is also not as big of an issue. I-90 has a relatively small presence in Seattle compared to I-5. It would also be significantly smaller without I-5 (there would be no reason to extend it west of Rainier Avenue). These two interstates weren’t always connected but I have to assume that at some point they would have been. The big problem in Seattle is I-5 and that happened a bit too early to stop.
The geography between Vancouver and Seattle is surprisingly similar but there are subtle differences. To be clear, Vancouver most definitely has freeways. This (https://maps.app.goo.gl/sY6YyTQbgADKW2Yt7) is a freeway and it is within the city limits (let alone the metro area). But it basically skirts Vancouver proper (unlike in Seattle, where they just rammed it through the heart of the city). I see a couple reasons for this. Canada runs east-west. The Trans-Canada Highway manages to skirt the main urban area while also providing another crossing (to go along with the Lions Gate Bridge Bridge). This means that Abbotsford, Surrey, Burnaby, Vancouver, North Vancouver and West Vancouver are all connected via a freeway. It may not go through the heart of each city but it connects them. In contrast, if you want to go from an American city (like Bellingham) to Vancouver (or North/West Vancouver) you will spend a lot of time on something other than a freeway.
It is hard to imagine they would do that in Seattle. There was great interest in connecting cities like Tacoma and Everett (just like there was in connecting Abbotsford, Surrey, Burnaby, etc. in B.C.). Unlike Vancouver though, there was no easy way to skirt the city. The closest analogy would be to bypass the city entirely. I-5 would use the current 405. I-90 (as a freeway) would end at Rainier Valley. 520 would end at Montlake. You could have parts of the existing I-5 extending into the city from the north and south but they wouldn’t go north of Jackson or south of the ship canal.
This means that you aren’t really skirting the city — you are bypassing it entirely. Of course the elephant in the room is SR-99. They could have easily just made it the main freeway through town. While not up to current standards, it is basically a freeway from Green Lake to South Lake Union and a full-fledged freeway south of there. You would need to do the most work north of Green Lake. While a freeway on Aurora sounds horrible to urbanists (like me) it would be the I-5, leaving the existing pathway of I-5 (in Seattle) with normal surface streets. There would probably be more lanes along with safer (but uglier) ramps on Aurora. I-90 would probably still be connected to I-5 (most likely with viaducts) but 520 would probably just end at Montlake. Some urban planners would propose connecting 520 and I-5 but it would likely come too late in the decade. Likewise, some would suggest a second freeway but it wouldn’t happen (just as the Thomson expressway didn’t happen). We would have only one north-south freeway through downtown instead of two (and it would most likely be tunneled). With less to maintain there would likely be pressure to cap it to the north as well, at least as far as Green Lake. I think this is the most realistic of the “dream” scenarios.
Throughout most of the 20th century, freeways in the U.S. were seen as modernizing transportation for the future, while all other forms of transportation, including buses, streetcars, even walking, were viewed as legacy transportation systems, not worth investing in. Only after the freeways we’re built did the downsides of them start to become clear, but by then, it was too late.
I did not watch the video, but I’m guessing that Vancouver was late enough to the freeway game that they could see from many U.S. examples that running a freeway right to downtown is not good for the city, so they wanted to do things differently. They probably also had a less powerful freeway construction lobby.
Freeways were also used to facilitate “blight abatement” aka removal of communities of people of color while plowing connections straight to central business districts. Most countries outside the USA built “ring roads” around their downtown cores.
I think what’s interesting about Vancouver is how it doesn’t even have a ring road, and there are no major grade-separated freeways anywhere near its core.
TLDR; In the 1960s there were freeway proposals AND FREEWAY REVOLTS across North America. The revolt in Vancouver succeeded. The route would have gone through the middle of Chinatown and Gastown, which were then lower-income nonwhite neighborhoods. The public protested and got it canceled.
Only a tenth of the proposed freeways in the US were built, so the insanity went only so far. In Seattle, the Bay Freeway (Mercer Street area) would have connected a 99 freeway upgrade, I-5, and the proposed Thompson freeway on MLK. 15th Ave W was built as an expressway, and would probably have been upgraded or at least made more of an expressway too.
Do you guys have any idea how awful it was in cities when they were blighted by steam trains and horses? I remember talking to my grandma as a teenager and lamenting cars. She very quickly set me straight. Living anywhere near a train line was an awful, and probably cancerous experience, and the waste from horses made the rest very smelly. Then there was the terror of polio…
Because living near a freeway today isn’t an awful, cancerous, loud and smelly experience?
OK, but upgrading a street or boulevard or neighborhood to a freeway is making things much worse. Freeway/expressway cars go faster, use more fuel, spew more emissions, and induced demand generates more trips. The switch from “dirty” horses to “clean” cars was a half century before freeways, and the cars could only go 30 mph. In the 1920s only 10% of Seattlites had cars, and in the 1950s it was rare to have more than one car per family. So there were fewer cars around then. Their limited number and speed may have caused them to have less of an impact they did later, and to be seen as relatively more environmental than horses. That era was long gone by the time freeways began to be built.
In one article I ran across some years ago, it was stated that if the Portland area Mt Hood Freeway and interchanges were built, it would have taken out some 10% of Portland’s housing.
Sure, there were good reasons to replace horses with automobiles.
That doesn’t mean too many automobiles are a good thing, or don’t come with extensive societal costs.
DM, do some research. There’s no way that today’s auto pollution comes close to what it was in my childhood. Leaded gas and no emission controls until around 1970. And that was still way better than coal dust and smoke from coal fires. Not to mention the continuous clang and roar from switching yards. For most of the industrial era cities were places people fled from as soon as they made enough money. About 100 years ago ancestors of mine bought land 60 miles south of NYC, near the end of the then new commuter railroad, as soon as they had money to escape. Other relatives operated a farm in the Castskills, and made it thru the depression boarding children of city families all summer. Their parents were desperate to get them away from the Polio virus. Cities as pleasant, habitable places that you lived in by choice is a very new phenomenon, and still only true in the developed world.
BTW, I don’t know about Seattle in the 60s, but in the northeastern city I lived in, there was ZERO demand for lakefront properties – the smell made it highly undesirable. And of course there was always the risk of the lake catching fire.
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/03/20/childhood-leukemia-linked-to-heavy-traffic-exposure-cdc-says/6658919/
https://airqualitynews.com/health/living-near-a-busy-road-increases-lung-cancer-risk-by-10/
Sure, correlation does not equal causation and conditions are certainly better than they were, but it still isn’t good.
The origin of Metro was to create a county wide sewer district; mainly to clean up Lake Washington where most of the homes were dumping raw sewerage into the lake. It was actually a combined sewer and transportation agency for quite some time. When Seattle Transit was on the verge of collapse “Metro” was the only County wide agency that could tax and spend on a regional basis. And the agreement lead to years of empty buses being added to the eastside to “pay back” the money to bail out Seattle Transit (largely their pension fund). Back then virtually every bus ran from “somewhere” on the eastside to DT Seattle. It was a “star” or “hub & spoke” system so pretty much only useful if you were commuting. So of course mid-day buses were mostly empty. And of course this coincided with auto ownership becoming ubiquitous. Even HS kids had cars or had a friend that had a car (everything creeps up from CA). That was the switch from one car per household to two or more cars. And since bus service was mostly useless that’s how the eastside developed.
Cars pollute far less from the tailpipe than they did prior to the 80s & 90s when fuel injection and computers took over engine management. But a nasty source of pollution from cars remains brake dust and particles from tire wear. There’s been links to goal keepers in soccer having health issues from the synthetic “turf” fields which are almost always a fake grass mat with a bed of ground up tires. Brakes don’t have asbestos in them anymore but the fine dust particles still aren’t good. And then there’s the oil and other fluids that leach into the environment. Don’t think that’s much; watch how many spin out accidents there are after the first rain following a dry stretch. And the shear number of cars/traffic has grown substantially since the 70’s. EVs still have the brake dust and tire wear pollution. And that’s not to mention the incremental demand for electricity is primarily carbon based. At least it’s nat-gas instead of coal which is better used to run turbines and generate electricity vs flaring it off at the well like most of it now. Look at a night sky image today and the Dakota’s look like a major metropolitan area because of all the oil rigs burning of the excess
gas.
Only after the freeways we’re built did the downsides of them start to become clear, but by then, it was too late.
It was more than that. From the very beginning they were controversial. Thus if Ike — often referred to as the “father of the American Interstate System” — had his way, they would look a lot like what they do in Vancouver. Keep in mind, this still isn’t great but it is a lot nicer than what is typically found in North America. There is just a lot less damage to the neighborhood. It also makes them less attractive as a means of transportation and in turn quite likely leads to less sprawl* .
There was a change in attitude but this had more to do with sensibilities. The same thing could be said about the Vietnam war** (as the video pointed out). This was the era of questioning authority and post-war assumptions. This included the war, civil rights and women’s liberation but also the environment and city planning. So while some might have opposed large-scale freeways in the city from the get-go, by the end of the decade they were willing to protest (and take other actions) to stop it.
*For example, SeaBus can compete with driving to Downtown Vancouver (for some trips). That is because once you get to Vancouver via the Lions Gate Bridge (on what is essentially a freeway) you have to slog your way on surface streets. As I write this it takes about ten minutes just to go a ways on the surface highway. In contrast, a similar trip on I-5 takes three minutes.
**In the 1950s there wasn’t much opposition to our involvement in Vietnam but by the late 60s there was a lot. To be clear a lot of this had to do with the fact that so many Americans were dying but it was also clear (to a lot of people) that our involvement was making things worse in Vietnam (and eventually the surrounding area).
Also Canada doesn’t really have a freeway system that connects across different province well enough. Some of the US cities has tons of long distance through traffic cutting near its suburbs like I-294 in Chicago and I-285 in Atlanta. Both have very high truck percentages for urban freeway.
EU has a better freeway network but they also have better alternatives for intercity passengers to avoid highway.
China has a similar national turnpike system to US Interstate’s scale, but driving long distance is more expensive because of gas price and distance-based toll rate similar to Pennsylvania turnpike.
Today Community Transit officially turns 50. From leasing school buses to connecting buses to light rail is crazy to think about.
It makes sense for an area transitioning from rural. School buses were what they had.
Yeah, and Community Transit has never been bigger than ever. I love the evolution.
Webmaster, check your email. There is a page two submission sitting there.
I haven’t seen this email. I’m checking with the other editors. What address did you send it to? You have a WordPress account, so you can create the article yourself. Then if you don’t have permission to publish it, press the review button to request a review.
Michael Smith found an email September 13th he thinks is it. I didn’t receive it, so I can’t do anything until somebody forwards it. In the meantime, it’s easiest for us if you enter the article into WordPress yourself, since that’s what we’d do.
Metro has released their latest restructure plan, and here’s what they plan to do:
With Stride S1 right around the corner and the new Renton TC opening, Metro is looking into ways to complement these changes and better serve the people in the area. Here are the ideas they came up with for the first phase:
– Redirect all current Renton TC bus routes to the new transit center (except for the 101, F Line, and future I Line.
– Change the overlapping part of the Metro FLEX areas of Renton Highlands and Bryn Mawr-Skyway to the new Renton TC rather than the current one.
– All current 102 trips that end at South Renton P&R (future Renton TC) would become 101 trips.
– The 101, F Line, and I Line (currently the 160) would not go into the current Renton TC, but stop outside of it.
– The F Line no longer uses 16th/Lind/7th to Rainier Ave from Oaksdale , it would instead use Oaksdale/Grady to Rainier Ave (stopping at the new Renton TC).
– The 143 is formally deleted.
With these changes, the growing Black Diamond community loses their opportunity to keep their one-seat ride to Seattle, the F Line, I Line, and the 101 still stop in the vicinity of Renton TC for some reason (Metro will likely refer to this area as “Downtown Renton” like how the 532/535 continue from Bellevue TC into Downtown Bellevue), and 16th loses their bus service.
Aside from that, I wholeheartedly support these changes. The F Line could become more direct, service could be somewhat simplified with the 102 trips to South Renton P&R (aka future Renton TC) becoming 101 trips (despite travel time added due to the Downtown Renton routing), and we straight up delete the 143 that surprisingly wasn’t deleted in Fall 2026 along with all the other suspended South King routes (that and the 186).
Metro needs to interline the 105 with the 101, 106, or 107 so that people can go somewhere further than downtown Renton without a half-hour transfer wait. It’s in Metro Connects but it’s not in this proposal.
“Service levels would remain the same on all other Metro routes in Renton” besides the 102 and 907. So the 105 won’t even get a frequency boost to mitigate its orphan routing. That’s understandable because it’s a revenue-neutral restructure, but the point is the restructure still doesn’t meet Renton’s mobility needs.
“the growing Black Diamond community loses their opportunity to keep their one-seat ride to Seattle”
Even after growing, it’s still probably small, exurban, and car-oriented. Is there more than a few unwalkable big-box stores and strip malls? I would be extremely surprised if it has sprouted something like downtown Everett. So why should an exurban community on the far side of Renton have a peak express to Seattle? They can go to Renton and transfer, or use the proposed-expanded 907 (that was expanded partly to mitigate the loss of the express, and to support more off-peak trips since that’s the direction ridership is going.
“Metro needs to interline the 105 with the 101, 106, or 107 so that people can go somewhere further than downtown Renton without a half-hour transfer wait.”
Yes twin, I’ve mused having a bus route from Renton Highlands to Downtown Seattle via the 101 path but then takes the 105/111 path. Such a route would have made a decent replacement for the 111 (which just got truncated at South Bellevue Station). Renton Highlands is underrated and needs better bus service.
“So why should an exurban community on the far side of Renton have a peak express to Seattle?”
It’s historically been tied to Seattle via rail, but ideally every city like Black Diamond (e.g: Orting, DuPont) should have a connection to Seattle or close enough (like a Link or Sounder connection).
“They can go to Renton and transfer, or use the proposed-expanded 907”
But there’s not a lot of good connections at Renton TC. The service to Seattle is basically just an express and that’s it. In order to justify a transfer it needs to be something like Link or Sounder. I understand what you’re trying to say but there needs to be at least more service on the 907 corridor or a better connection at Renton.
Part of the problem with transit to Black Diamond (and Maple Valley, etc.) is that the road doesn’t have HOV lanes. Thus the bus is stuck in the same traffic as cars. It might offer a more comfortable trip, but not a faster one. This in turn limits the popularity and cost-effectiveness of the route, especially during peak. Throw in working from home (which is bound to impact trips from Black Diamond a lot more than it would trips from say, Ballard) and I can see why the 907 is sufficient to handle demand.
This is a general problem. Worse yet, we add lanes that are not HOV. This was the case with SR-522 to Monroe. They added lanes but regular lanes (not HOV). The HOV lanes don’t start until Bothell. This in turn makes peak-only service less attractive. At the same time, there isn’t enough demand to support all-day service, especially since it is expensive to go all the way to Monroe. Thus they are stuck in this nasty in-between state: enough demand to cause major traffic jams but not enough to support decent transit.
It is a classic example of how screwed up zoning is in America — we allow sprawl but restrict urban development. Then we struggle to pay for the road infrastructure that would enable people to get from one place to another without sitting in a huge traffic jam. Worse yet, we add lanes that are not HOV. This was the case with 522 to Monroe. They added lanes but regular lanes (not HOV). (The HOV lanes don’t start until Bothell.)
Surprised that they decided to send F to SW Grady Way. I thought F is like what it is today to avoid SW Grady Way traffic. Renton is making SW 7th an active transportation corridor and is putting multi-use path there. Isn’t it a better street to run bus?
Pinehurst station has its first elevator outage.
And so did Star Lake on the first day of service.
Central Link’s opening was delayed simply because Sound Transit needed to work a little more on Beacon Hill’s elevators (since it was the only way to enter the station).
Imo there needs to be elevator testing as much as how there’s simulated service testing for the trains and station stops.
What a cool video!! I haven’t heard of this creator before but I enjoy his style. One of my favorite things about Vancouver is there are no freeways in the city proper, except of course, the Trans-Canada Highway on the very eastern edge. I’m so glad the freeway revolts of the 1960s succeeded there.
Yeah, I enjoyed it as well. He is witty and provided just enough information to make it worth watching.
I could have done without the drug/psychedelic stunts, but the video addressed an issue that’s directly relevant to us and everyone has overlooked: Vancouver doesn’t have freeways except in its periphery, but why not? Was there a decision to do that?
Northbound Link train is/was stuck at IDC Station, trains being turned back, bus bridges being called up. This was as of a few minutes ago. All of this may have changed by now.
Turnbacks at Judkins, Westlake, and Stadium.
Seems to be clearing up. Blocking train cleared.
Link was running fine for me at 8:15 pm. I boarded at SeaTac after flying back today.
Is the lack of comments about Pinehurst Station since its opening a sign that its importance to North Seattle was overstated?
I think it says more about the overall fraction of people in Puget Sound that participate in this website.
Overstated by who? I’ve just been wondering how this gets built before Graham. Maybe Seattle didn’t want to give up least productive station honors to Least Main in Bellevue?
Sam, I visited Pinehurst Station this weekend. I missed the opening since it happened during the work week. Interestingly, there weren’t very many people using the brand new station on a sunny afternoon, especially with all the events going on in the city. As I was wrapping up my self-guided station tour I saw the new bus 77 coming westbound. I decided to check it out. I rode it through Lake City, the Roosevelt District and got off in the U District. After all the recent Link openings, Pinehurst felt very underwhelming but the 77 was kind of cool.
I’m sure there aren’t a lot of comments because the station is boring. This is a good thing. In contrast, Northgate is quite complicated. To be fair, it has a lot going on. The mezzanine is justified given the bridge to the college. The direct walkway to the mall/parking lot is valuable (I guess). But I still find it confusing and have gone down the wrong way more than once.
In contrast the Pinehurst Station is quite simple. It should have been a lot cheaper to build (although it wasn’t that expensive compared to the rest of Lynnwood Link). It has two platforms but it is quite obvious which one you go up, since you are outside. (In contrast I think I’ve gone down the wrong set of stairs at more than one downtown station.)
The more interesting thing is the connection with the buses and the other changes on the surface. This is a work in progress. They are still doing a lot of work on the road. They will widen the pathway to the west. Eventually the city council will get around to rezoning the area and then we’ll see a bunch of new apartments/condos. Likewise, there is always hope that Metro will provide something better than the obviously flawed 77 in the future (is there a bat-signal for Jarrett Walker?).
It is also an infill station. If Lynnwood Link did not include any other station then I’m sure it would have a similar response. Even some of the existing stations that are part of extensions haven’t gotten many comments. People go to the grand opening, maybe check out a few stations and then go about their business. But this lack of comments doesn’t mean initial low ridership, let alone low ridership in the long run. I don’t know if I’ve ever read about anyone using say, Star Lake Station but it got over 1,500 riders the last three months. I would expect ridership to start out slow at the station and then build as people realize it is a good option (even with the flawed Metro routing).
The bigger question that I think needs to be asked is what happens after HB 1491 is in effect for a decade or two.
https://futurewise.org/tod1491/
HB 1491 is the mandated transit oriented development law that requires a higher FAR and forgives parking minimums within a half-mile of a station.
However, so much of the half mile radius of Pinehurst Station is taken by I-5 or Jackson Park Golf Course. So its impact seems more muted than at other Link stations.
I am one of those who expect low ridership at the station. Others are more optimistic. We should know after a few months of operation. And how Metro riders use Route 77 will take several months before that info is available.
However, so much of the half mile radius of Pinehurst Station is taken by I-5 or Jackson Park Golf Course. So its impact seems more muted than at other Link stations.
Yes, but that is true of every station in Lynnwood Link as well as many other stations. I still find it odd that people say things about Pinehurst Station while ignoring the fact that it is true of other stations. The only reason people focus on Pinehurst is because it was not included initially.
I’m sure the same thing would happen with any other station (other than Lynnwood). If we have Pinehurst and 185th do we really need a station at South Shoreline given that (in your words) so much of the half mile radius of Pinehurst Station is taken by I-5 or Jackson Park Golf Course. What if we had every station but Mountlake Terrace. Then it becomes “so much of the half mile radius of Pinehurst Station is taken by I-5 or Nile Shrine Golf Course”. Only Mountlake Terrace doesn’t have a golf course — instead those words can be replaced with “green belt”. Oh, and even Lynnwood Station has that. Again, none of the stations within Lynnwood Link have good development potential. Zero. Zilch. All of them require bus feeders and (to a certain degree) large parking lots. But if we ignore the former do we really need so much of the latter? Remember, Northgate has an enormous amount of parking. If we assume that every station is highly dependent on parking then why build so many? If bus integration doesn’t matter, if building an obviously better bus network doesn’t matter, if the the only thing that matters is walk-up potential and park and ride lots then maybe we shouldn’t have any stations between Lynnwood and Northgate. Just build bigger parking lots at each station and call it a day. You don’t save that much money (these are above ground stations after all) but you still save some.
That is absurd, of course. Bus integration does matter. A better bus network does matter. However limited, the walk-up ridership adds up. Pinehurst Station (just like both Shoreline stations and the one in Mountlake Station) are definitely worth it, assuming the cost of building Lynnwood Link (most of which is for the line itself) is worth it.
There were hardly any comments at all between Friday and Sunday. I almost told the commentariat it was below quota and not up to Sam’s standards. But you got to it first.
I’ve tried to go up there a few times but plans kept falling through. On opening day I went north to the station at 5:30pm, intending to see the station area and ride the 77, but I also needed to get to Costco for something my relative needed urgently, and I had my work equipment in my backpack. So in the end I looked down from the train but didn’t get off, and continued to Shoreline North. I was hoping to get Swift Blue in its 10-minute daytime frequency, but I got there and it was a 9 minute wait, and I decided it wasn’t worth it to do that transfer and have a longer walk to get to a location that has the products in less familiar and less convenient locations, so I turned around and, would you believe it, went to the SODO Costco.
I haven’t had a reason to go to Lake City since Wednesday, and with Fred Meyer and Value Village gone, that’s two fewer reasons. I’ll get there sometime. My support for the station is primarily for residents of Lake City and Bitter Lake and Pinehurst, and would-be future residents and shoppers. Those are a lot more numerous than just me.
“HB 1491 is the mandated transit oriented development law that requires a higher FAR and forgives parking minimums within a half-mile of a station.”
The city wanted Pinehurst station in 2016 and said it would upzone the station area. It procrastinated on the upzone for years but finally did something. I think it wants to do more now but it’s being held up for a citywide environmental review to justify Wilson’s citywide upzones. So the city council procrastinated 5-7 years longer than it should have, but the station area is getting upzoned, regardless of the state mandate.
So the state mandate wasn’t necessary for Pinehurst’s case, and I doubt it requires more than the city did anyway. It may even require less.
It procrastinated on the upzone for years but finally did something.
Did it though? I thought they still haven’t approved the changes. According to this map it is still neighborhood residential.
Oh, and according to that map, so is the area (within Seattle) close to the 148th Station. That station has been there for years now and still they haven’t passed the upzone. The closest area with an upzone is close to 15th & 145 (which has seen some recent new development). Seattle has been dragging its feet when it comes to Lynnwood Link while Shoreline actually made some changes.
chttps://one-seattle-plan-zoning-implementation-seattlecitygis.hub.arcgis.com/pages/zoning-map
Look like MR2, 8 stories. Though might still be in the courts.
Yeah, I know the proposal (they talked about it for years). I just didn’t know if it was ever actually signed into law.
EIS appeals. Per the website:
“Council began review of this legislation in April but put their work on hold in July due to an ongoing appeal of environmental analysis. We anticipate that Council will restart their review of the legislation in early 2027.”
Does KCM have a hotspot map of where to most amount of delays occurs? I would be really useful as we could see visually where bus improvements are needed instead of an anecdotal “oh the 372 gets delayed at the intersection of x and y for 5 minutes everyday”
In theory, this could be created with GPS location pings on phones. The problem is figuring out the cause. Is the bus stopped more often because of a signal that’s ill-timed, becatt urea of a bus merge that is difficult or because it has a higher share of wheelchair riders that use a stop? So it’s more useful as a screening tool but not in assigning a specific automatic solution.
It should also be feasible to do this with Metro’s live bus tracking data. They certainly do this analysis internally when determining where to do bus improvements, but I haven’t seen a system-wide map.
It’d probably have to be personal/unofficial project.
A while back “lurker: referenced this document with a priority list by corridor (not route). They only considered routes that they aren’t planning on improving (as part of the last transportation levy). They ranked projects based on congestion as well as the number of riders impacted by it. The latter was based on the total ridership of the routes that go along the corridor. This is a reasonable approach given congestion impacts everyone on the corridor directly and indirectly. Riders who are “down stream” of the congested area have to deal with delays which are not consistent. This in turn leads to irregular frequency and worse, bus bunching. Even if this isn’t a problem it impacts the cost of the trip, which impacts everyone. The cost is based on frequency and trip time but the total ridership of the route influences frequency (high ridership routes tend to run more often). Thus this approach is good overall.
The only major flaw is that it assumes that routes don’t change. Consider 85th NW for example. It has been served by the 45 for years. But now the 61 also runs along the corridor, impacting those riders as well. Thus the impact of congestion along 85th has gone up. Except with the most recent change, the 45 is no longer paired with the 75. It just ends at the triangle. Thus ridership on that bus went down. Thus moves the needle up and down. Not only that, but very congested corridors are often avoided for this very reason. The C and D line are no longer paired because congestion (especially around the Ballard Bridge) made the pairing unreliable.
Yet despite this flaw I think it is a good metric. I think it makes sense as a starting point. The other big issue is how easy is to fix a congested area. There are parts of the 44 for example that can’t be easily fixed (where there are other parts that can). Sometimes it is best to get the low hanging fruit rather than worry about whether it is the sweetest.
[Note: I updated the comment as I found the previous comment and the document that was referenced]
Depending on your definition of delay. In traffic engineering world, vehicle delay is actual travel time minus free-flow travel time, but in transit performance measure, delay is how much the bus is behind schedule.
During busy hours, schedule is usually adjusted to make it easier for bus to arrive on time, so a 0 minute delay only means the scheduling team does an awesome job to predict the travel time. It doesn’t mean bus doesn’t get stuck in traffic and have room for travel time improvement.
Therefore, I don’t think transit improvement corridor identification is just about transit real-time data. I think in order to identify corridors for transit travel time improvement, they should also look at traffic corridor congestion level. The most congested corridor without transit priority should be the highest priority for transit priority treatment.
I think in order to identify corridors for transit travel time improvement, they should also look at traffic corridor congestion level.
That is basically what the report looked at (that I referenced in the previous comment).
Earlier this morning, I was looking for train tickets between New York and Philadelphia, with costs running at around $100-$150 per person, each on the Northeast regional line, or $200-$300 on the Acela. This on top of having to pay an additional $100/round trip for the privilege of carrying my dog.
It is insane how expensive train travel in the U.S. has become. How are you going to get people to take the train over driving when, even for people that do not have cars, a rental car is hundreds of dollars cheaper?
Rental cars have also become much more expensive, especially when you take into account all the local taxes and fees that politicians seem to think have no downside, because you are taxing non-voters, for the most part. And gas. Don’t forget gas.
As someone who rides the Cascades a fair amount and often struggle to book a last-minute (or a seat within a week or two, at peak times) trip to Eugene or either Vancouver, I suspect that they have room to raise Cascade prices. It clearly makes sense when I’m travelling alone. It’s when I’m bringing the family it starts to feel expensive.
Except the average cost to go from NYC to Philly by train is much lower than that.
It says if you book in advance, round trip tickets can be as low as $22 to $40. Last minute tickets are closer to your quotes. But, yes, Amtrak can get expensive. I think it’s interesting how it can sometimes be so much more costly than flying. So, I don’t think a lot of people balk at the train ticket price, then opt to drive. I think they opt to fly.
Rental car companies have started routinely sending us bills after we return the car, insisting on an extra $500 or so for imaginary damages detected by their AI scanner or something. At least it’s happened the last 2 times.
What rental agency? We’ve had good luck with Enterprise. We managed to rip the valance panel off the bumper while on a trip in Yellowstone. We threw it in the trunk and figured we would pay for it when we returned the car (and if it was really expensive we would have insurance pay for it). We mentioned it and they didn’t charge us anything. We have been using Enterprise a lot and maybe they cut us a break but even so, they were great.
Hertz.
Yeah, I’ve had good luck with Enterprise. Not using Hertz again.
The attempt to buy the train tickets was with about three weeks advance notice.
I should also note that the cheapest tickets all had departure times at very odd hours. If you wanted to not leave very early in the morning or arrive very late at night, it was starting at around $125 for regular service, $250 for Acela service. Multiply by 4 (2 adults, 2 directions), then add the $100 pet fee, it adds up fast. The $100 pet fee is also ridiculous, given that the pet is in a carrier and cannot leave hair or messes behind. It’s essentially them milking the customer, taking advantage of the fact that intercity buses generally disallow pets (except service animals) altogether, leaving rental cars as the only competition.
Anyway, going back to our trip, at the times we wanted, the grand total for two adults, plus one dog added up to $694, and would still require the person we were meeting to drive 30 minutes into downtown Philly to pick us up. With a rental car, we only needed one day, a the trip is a day trip. The total was around $88, after taxes and fees. The pickup is at Newark Airport, eliminating the traffic hassles of driving through NYC and the tunnels leaving in and out of it. Even adding another $34 (also very high) to take public transportation to the rental car facility, plus an unknown amount for electricity and tolls on the NJ Turnpike, we’re still saving over $500 compared to taking the train. And, we don’t need to ask the person to drive out of their way to pick us up and drop us off.
This should not be the case. But, it’s what happens when rail is priced to make a profit (the NE corridor does turn a profit, which subsidizes service on other routes), rather than serve the public.
Yeah, that’s a lot. The day trip aspect definitely makes it substantially more expensive compared to the rental.
And I agree with your larger point that our federal government should be subsidizing the infrastructure at least at the level that they subsidize highways, waterways, and airports, preferably more, given their differential environmental impacts.
That said, I’ve recently done similar distance several day-trips between Tacoma and Vancouver, and they have cost a fraction of that – under $100 round-trip for business class. I’m not sure why the differential. Does owning their own tracks make it MORE expensive?
Maybe Cascades passengers benefit (from ticket prices, not smooth, fast ride) from BNSF not bothering to maintain their tracks very well.
The Northeast Corridor (which doesn’t receive state subsidies for operations) uses airline-style demand pricing. If the trains are close to full (or projected to be full by the pricing algorithm and the humans who supervise it), prices go up. I believe state-supported routes like Cascades in general don’t use demand pricing.
Cost has nothing directly to do with pricing when demand-based pricing is used; the trains are running with a more-or-less fixed number of seats and a predetermined schedule, and the goal is to maximize revenue within that constraint. That includes higher fares when the seats will sell anyway and lower fares to stimulate demand if not. Long term, if costs are lower than revenue (including subsidies), they can increase capacity to increase revenue and profit, but that isn’t cheap or easy. And vice versa: if revenue (including subsidies) is below costs, they can decrease capacity to reduce costs.
Cascades has been using demand pricing for a couple decades. But the state subsidy keeps prices lower than they’d otherwise be.
Washington state subsidizes Cascades.
I think Northeast Regional is a little bit pricey, but it is not ridiculously pricey.
Acela is definitely too expensive. The problem is that it is not even fast enough to be that pricey.
Acela’s popularity is largely made possible by scheduling the train at popular time. If there was always a NER departing Penn Station around the same time as Acela, Acela wouldn’t be nearly as unpopular as it is today.
There usually is a NER departing Penn Station around the same time as Acela. Often there will be a NER train departing just minutes before after Acela. This is more obvious at the beginning of the line (trains departing Washington nothbound), where for the most part Regional trains leave 5-15 minutes after an Acela train.
I generally agree; it’s fairly rare that I care about the time savings Acela offers enough to pay the fare difference (though sometimes the fares are comparable: on the random date I happen to be looking at, the 15:25-18:24 Acela is $62 and the 15:30-18:58 Regional $58, and the 16:02-19:24 Regional is more expensive ($82) than the 16:20-19:20 Acela ($62)). People use Acela anyway, so clearly some people see it as valuable. In the NE Corridor there’s enough supply so they can offer both alternatives, which is great. Acela profit subsidizes much of the rest of Amtrak.
Yeah, it is common to charge more for faster service in Europe as well. The difference is that in Europe the trains are faster at every level. They tend to be cheaper as well.
I don’t know about the Continent but they are not cheaper in the UK. When my cousin comes over from England he and his wife are amazed at how cheap the train and transit in general is to “back home”. They’ve also commented on how spacious the seating is. Of course the option to drive in England, especially around London, is much more expensive than here and a large percentage of the time slower. So it’s easier for them to charge more; especially when the trains are generally full.
What are train prices in other countries? Compared to:
A. A New York – Philadelphia type trip on a basic speed line.
B. A New York – Philadelphia type trip on a high speed line.
C. A DC-Boston type trip on a basic speed line. (Northeast corridor end-to-end.)
D. A DC-Boston type trip on a high speed line.
E. A Seattle-Portland type trip on a basic speed line.
F. A Seattle-Portland type trip on a high speed line.
G. A Seattle-Oakland (California) type trip on a basic speed line.
H. A Seattle-Oakland (California) type trip on a high speed line.