An image included in Dan Strauss’ weekly newsletter lists nine elected officials and Sound Transit representatives expected to speak at the event.

Seattle City Councilmember (District 6) and Sound Transit Boardmember Dan Strauss is hosting a community form discussing the Ballard Link Extension alongside several other elected officials and Sound Transit representatives. The forum will be held in the Osberg Great Hall at the National Nordic Museum on Monday, October 19, from 6-8pm.

In a newsletter emailed to constituents last week, Dan Strauss announced the event while highlighting his efforts to get Sound Transit to commit to building the full Ballard Link Extension to Market Street. These included requiring Sound Transit staff to determine when the agency would be able to complete the Ballard Link Extension under current conditions, and looking for ways to reduce project costs in order to open the extension sooner. Currently, the agency expects to open the SODO to Seattle Center portion of the Ballard Link Extension in 2042.

In July, Sound Transit fulfilled Strauss’ first requirement with the announcement the rest of the project could be delayed to 2060 unless significant cost savings are found. When voters passed ST3 in 2016, the entire Ballard Link Extension was expected to open in 2035. In 2021, this schedule slipped to 2037 or 2039 as Sound Transit realized the cost to build a second Link-only tunnel under downtown and managing other complications would far exceed expectations. After calculating “bottom-up” cost estimates for the proposed design of the extension last year, the agency found the full project could cost nearly twice its previous estimate. Compounded with exploding cost estimates across ST3, the Sound Transit Board voted to defer construction of line past Seattle Center until costs were reduced or additional revenue were found.

“Bottom-up” cost estimates listed in Sound Transit’s 2026 Budget and Financial Plan show significant overages for every Link expansion project authorized under ST3 (Sound Transit).

Sound Transit says it may be able to open the full extension in 2042 if the agency can reduce the total estimated cost by $1 billion (or identify that much in new revenue), begin acquiring property by 2030, finish design by 2032, and lock in funding to start construction by 2033. Regardless, Ballard Link advocates remain dedicated to pushing Sound Transit to return to the originally promised date of opening in 2035.

With a lot of work and a bit of luck, the Ballard Link Extension could open by 2042 (Sound Transit).

At the community forum, Sound Transit is expected to share more about its proposed timeline for the Ballard Link Extension, the work agency staff have been doing to reduce costs, and its next steps for the project. There will also be a Q&A session.

Those interested in a seat should probably arrive early. The National Nordic Museum is located at the intersection of 28th Ave NW and NW Market Street, just under a mile west of the planned terminus of the Ballard Link Extension. Nearby bus stops are served by King County Metro Routes 17 and 44.

72 Replies to “Ballard Link Community Forum on October 19”

      1. If I took D, I’d totally wait for 44 there rather than walking.
        44 is one of few service that I would consider riding only two or three stops just to avoid 10 minutes of walk. I wish it could run every 10 minutes on the weekend too.

  1. 5:30p – pregame at Smoke Shop
    6:00p – yell at Wilson and Constantine
    8:01p – return to Smoke Shop for $10 dinner

    1. Is Smoke Shop a tobacco-bongs-weed place or a restaurant or both? If it’s the former, I’d consider this off-topic.

      1. Ballard Smoke Shop is a popular “old Ballard” dive bar/diner. I think the concept of “pregaming” a community forum regarding a beleaguered mass transit line is funny.

      2. It’s a restaurant on Ballard Ave. But how is that more on topic than a place with bongs? Burgers and Beer are not allowed to be consumed on buses any more than tobacco and weed.

      3. If it were a weed shop, it impugns on the value of the meeting (so unimportant it doesn’t matter if you go there stoned), the quality of any feedback you’d provide, and is an inappropriate use of the comments. Since I didn’t know what the Smoke Shop was, I wanted to check what it was first before presuming anything.

        1. Is being “stoned” really that much different than being drunk? Excessive inebriation is excessive inebriation. If anything, it would be less disruptive to show up buzzed on weed instead of booze.

          Anyways, I think it’s OK not to take this event seriously. But maybe I only think that because ST is obviously and completely uninterested in the kind of deep reset that would actually be needed to deliver BLE for less than thirty billion year-of-expenditure dollars.

        2. I think it is absolutely critical to take this event seriously, as if we are serious and direct enough that the politicians will have to be serious with us.

        3. It is neither a weed store nor a place to smoke. It’s an old Ballard haunt for the fishing industry. If you love dive bars, the place is for you. They are famous for their fried chicken, cheap prices, and the old cigarette machine in the main bar. The walls are covered with vintage pictures of fishing boats and fishing people. It is to be respected and cherished. And it’s a great place for folks to gather and discuss the issues of the day.

        4. Yikes, Mike. I understand you want to maintain moderation of the comment section. But also understand that not all transit nerds are built the same. And my feedback for our leaders is just as important as yours – whether or not I have a drink at my neighborhood bar. Chill STB.

  2. Just a note that the cost table in the post omits the new OMF costs. They are listed in the referenced report on the next table:

    OMF North and OMF South show higher cost estimates too.

    And the table is from last year. Word is emerging that these cost estimates are still higher for some of these projects.

    1. Yeah, it was the best summary table I could quickly find. I’m very interested to see ST’s 2027 Budget and Financial Plan.

  3. Anybody else getting deja vu on how University Link also climbed in cost mainly because of the Ship Canal crossing and was delayed over a decade? Well, that’s the same case with Ballard Link. Another similarity to point out is that they were both active projects during a BUDGET SHORTFALL.

    Not only that, but the Ballard monorail project would have cost 11 billion to build and Ballard Link costed 11 billion at one point before the sudden increase to nearly double the project cost.

    One solution Sound Transit seriously needs to look into is rerouting Ballard Link to UW. Of course it’s not Downtown but the closest you can get to Downtown without spending a fortune (basically sending it to the second largest destination in the city).

    Does anybody else also have an issue with Ballard Link being redundant with the D Line? Because I seriously do and the 15th Ave alignment would carry low ridership, so I think we should instead upgrade the D Line and re-route Ballard Link to UW Station via Fremont where the neighborhood is actually walkable unlike Interbay.

    Also place the station in Ballard in the actual heart and not at a congested intersection. I would love to have the D Line split at Market St and head to Ballard Station rather than continuing up 15th and ignoring the neighborhood with the northern branch of the D Line extending to Northgate/Lake City. Market St ideally should be a transit mall if we’re going to make it a regional destination with a Link station.

    1. “Anybody else getting deja vu on how University Link also climbed in cost mainly because of the Ship Canal crossing and was delayed over a decade? Well, that’s the same case with Ballard Link. Another similarity to point out is that they were both active projects during a BUDGET SHORTFALL.”

      Those were different issues in different eras. ST was afraid the construction risk of its preferred Ship Canal alignment (the Portage Bay one) might lead to cost overruns so large it would sink the entire initial segment so there would be no Link at all. After living through the failure of Forward Thrust and how it set us back two decades, that was too much to contemplate. ST’s conservatism on the Ship Canal at least allowed Westlake-SeaTac to open and gave some mobility improvement to Rainier Valley (a lower-income walkable district that’s just the kind that should have a metro).

      When U-Link restarted a half decade later, ST reevaluated the other alternative (the Montlake one), and found it unrisky enough to be doable.

      Ballard/DSTT2 has completely different issues. ST has not raised any particular construction risk with a Ship Canal tunnel (or high bridge). The cost problems are downtown, and putting West Seattle ahead of it. The costs are not due to risky soils (unlike the Ship Canal or First Hill), but because the tunnel is so deep, real-estate prices have escalated, and materials and labor just went through supply-chain bottlenecks and inflation. If we don’t build Ballard/DSTT2/WS, we still have ST2 Link on Lynnwood-FW and Lynnwood-Redmond — the most essential core of Link. People in Ballard indirectly benefit from ST2 Link even if they have a 30-45 minute last-3-miles overhead to get to it. That wasn’t the case in 2000 when the Ship Canal crossing was deferred.

      Also, I’m not sure if your premise is accurate. Did U-Link’s definite costs rise so much either when it was deferred or when it was revived? I recall the final U-Link came in under budget (under its revised budget). The risk ST was referring to was potential unknown contingencies, not definite realized costs.

      1. “Did U-Link’s definite costs rise so much either when it was deferred or when it was revived? I recall the final U-Link came in under budget (under its revised budget).”

        U-Link came over budget in 2001 and was delayed from 2006 to 2016. The tail to U District was deferred and instead built in Northgate Link. Idk if U-Link came under budget but we can clarify that it was affordable for Sound Transit and it was built.

        1. The extension to Northgate from UWS (“North Link” finally) was under-budget, mostly because of the Covid recession.

      2. Y’all gonna get sick of me. But I’ll say it again and again. It all gets easier if ST doesn’t spend $5 billion on WSLE and take on all the associated debt service and operating costs. It’s not too late to stop a gargantuan mistake from happening.

        1. I get your point.

          I think people may get sick of me begging for level platform transfers at SODO. I wish more people (especially Board members) got what a horrific design mistake ST is making at SODO by making everyone use two sets of stairs up and back down.

    2. “the Ballard monorail project would have cost 11 billion to build and Ballard Link costed 11 billion at one point before the sudden increase to nearly double the project cost.”

      I’m not sure if this is for or against the Ballard monorail project. I don’t remember what it cost, but I do remember the agency didn’t know what it was doing, depended on an MVET an Eyman initiative revoked, and its finances were so tight it wouldn’t even accept cross-agency transfers, so I’d be stuck riding the bus to avoid paying double fare for a monorail+bus transfer. Also, it was maximum 35 mph (vs Link 55, or with theoretical track improvements 65), with partial single-tracking so frequency was capped at 20 minutes, and near the end, half of it was truncated (I don’t remember if it was Ballard or West Seattle). That was its last state before it couldn’t afford its financing and the public canceled it.

      Ballard Link doesn’t have any of these problems. It has other problems, but I’d say they’re still not as big as the monorail’s problems and limitations were.

    3. “One solution Sound Transit seriously needs to look into is rerouting Ballard Link to UW. Of course it’s not Downtown but the closest you can get to Downtown without spending a fortune”

      Ross thinks that too, and I’m sympathetic to that position. Even with a transfer, Ballard-UDistrict-Westlake would still be faster than the D or 40, because Ballard-Westlake is the long side of the triangle.

      Ballard-UDistrict would also cost less and have higher ridership per mile than Ballard-downtown, per ST’s corridor study in the 2010s.

      But there’s no way the board or the city will reverse McGinn’s preference for Ballard-downtown, or deprive SLU of Link. So the only alternatives are ST’s, a Ballard-Westlake shuttle, or an automated Ballard-West Seattle line with a new downtown alignment. (I’m leaving out elevated or surface because I don’t think they have a political chance. It’s either one of the above, or nothing.)

      1. “But there’s no way the board or the city will reverse McGinn’s preference for Ballard-downtown”

        Yeah, that seems highly unlikely especially that voters will argue over what they voted for in 2016. That was the reason why Sound Transit deferred a Everett Mall station on Everett Link.

        “or deprive SLU of Link.”

        SLU’s getting the First Hill treatment at this point.

      2. Yes, those are the options, though the full automated Ballard-West Seattle option is fading fast because of ST’s desire to “Start something!!! ANYthing!!!”.

        Just point out this:

        WSBLE as it was originally proposed is being “trimmed” — that is “shortened”.
        There are three places to shorten the project.
        They are: a. SoDo OR Delridge, b. Seattle Center, or c. SoDo AND Westlake

        Service to Neighborhoods:

        Option “a” removes service to the West Seattle plateau
        Option “b” removes service from Ballard but keeps it for Uptown/SLU
        Option “c” serves both West Seattle and Ballard/Uptown/SLU

        Operational Issues:

        Option “a” does not have Line 3 trains to run to Everett, unless they reverse at Forest Street. West Seattle riders lose their one-seat ride to UW.
        Option “b” severs the Spine in the middle of Seattle breaking North Seattle-Airport service and has lousy downtown stations for Rainier Valley folks.
        Option “c” builds the West Seattle Stub and that’s that. The express buses continue to do the heavy lifting for downtown travelers, because they get there just as fast — or faster — as even a “through” Link train would. And, they serve SLU directly. Also, since a mid-level opening bridge is much cheaper than either a tunnel or high bridge, that’s probably what will happen, so service to and from Ballard might be a bit unreliable some times of the day and year.

        Advantages:
        Option “a” avoids spending $7 billion while making transit worse for most riders.
        Option “b” pushes direct Airport access to Uptown and SLU
        Option “c” builds the “Ballard Stub” with a shallower, better Westlake and the ability to extend into First Hill.

        On balance option “c”, with all the engineering fixes we’ve worked out here on The Blog, makes the most sense. [Obviously, we haven’t done actual “engineering”, just pointed out places in the world where the same problems have been solved with methods that save money, mostly through automation and smaller trains.]

    4. “Does anybody else also have an issue with Ballard Link being redundant with the D Line?”

      It’s not redundant with the D any more than the MLK segment is redundant with the 106 or the South King County segment is redundant with the A. Link is a limited-stop express service. The D, 106, and A are for in-between stops and short-distance trips. Link’s direct competitor is the 15X. Metro should have made the 15X an all-day frequent route decades ago, so that Ballard could get to downtown/regional transfers in 20 minutes. But it didn’t; it kept it peak-only unidirectional. The 15 will surely go away with Ballard Link.

      Ballard’s ultimate problem — and the reason I moved out if it in 2003 — is there’s currently a 30-45 minute overhead to get to a regional transfer point (Westlake or U-District) on the D, 40, or 44. Most of my activities were outside Ballard — on Aurora, in east Seattle, or in Bellevue, so I incurred that overhead every time I went anywhere. Ballard’s isolation makes it hard to recommend it as a place to live or shop in: it means Ballard can’t fully participate in the walkable/transit-rich housing availability environment Seattle and the region needs.

      The way to fix that is to decrease Ballard’s isolation overhead. Get the Ballard-Westlake or Ballard-UDistrict travel time down to 20 minutes by bus or 10-15 minutes by subway. Ways to do this would be to run the 15 all day, dramatically speed up the D, 40, or 44; grade-separated rail; or a ROBUST tram like MLK (not like the SLU streetcar now). So those are your options.

    5. The activists that initially championed Ballard Link — voters in the 45th corridor and Seattle Subway (who convinced me) — supported the 2016 compromise assuming it would be like other Link extensions: similar cost range, similar downtown transfers, and not splitting the north-south spine. All those changes were ST decisions after the vote. When ST realized its 5th Avenue alignment would lead to 10-minute transfer walks, it should have gone back to the drawing board and looked for a better alternative or cancelled the project.

      Give that ST didn’t do that, and costs have ballooned, and the downtown transfers are still bad, and the CID stations are outside the CID, it’s time to look at, maybe we should just fall back to a bus solution after all. If Ballard Link isn’t built, we still have ST2 Link. The D and 40 can be improved like the 8 was. The 15 could become an all-day route. We have choices. We could even go for a lower-cost automated line or a high-quality tram line. The opposition against a Ballard streetcar concept in 2016 was fear that it wouldn’t be high-quality, that it would be as watered down and slow as the existing streetcar lines. If the city could convince the public it won’t make that mistake, then a Ballard tram could be more feasible. Especially compared to this DSTT2 monstrosity.

    6. Ballard to U District sounds good to me. Nobody really cares about going to Interbay.

      But we need a better solution for going to South Lake Union. The current streetcar isn’t cutting it.

      1. “we need a better solution for going to South Lake Union. The current streetcar isn’t cutting it.”

        We’ve got four frequent bus routes. C, 40, 62, and 70/future J. All of them are more frequent than the streetcar and go to more neighborhoods than just the 1-mile streetcar route. All of them were created/upgraded after the streetcar started. They aren’t melting down with overcrowding like the 8 was or the 71/72/73X were. Ross has suggested extending RapidRide H to SLU following the C alignment.

        1. “We’ve got four frequent bus routes. C, 40, 62, and 70/future J. All of them are more frequent than the streetcar and go to more neighborhoods than just the 1-mile streetcar route.”

          That’s the thing with First Hill, but you’ll never please people with that when it comes to areas like First Hill and SLU. They’re job centers and you need good transit for job centers like SLU and First Hill with major employers.

          “Ross has suggested extending RapidRide H to SLU following the C alignment.”

          Extending the H to SLU will be useless once West Seattle Link opens. I have a similar idea to that, and it’s extending the I Line to Renton Landing with the F Line since Metro doesn’t seem interested in truncating it at the new Renton TC and wants it to continue into downtown. The 560 won’t serve Renton Landing as the Stride S1 so at least give it another RapidRide.

        2. Extending the H to SLU will be useless once West Seattle Link opens.

          Right. And none of it will matter once the sun becomes a white dwarf.

          Seriously though, West Seattle Link won’t reach downtown until 2042, assuming there aren’t further delays. That is a long time from now. Until then, it is highly likely that West Seattle buses will continue downtown. It is silly to worry about what the routes will look like after that. We are talking about buses, after all. They can easily be re-routed. But the C and H are a natural pairing (and not just because it makes me think of pure cane sugar from Hawaii). They are both RapidRide Lines that go from West Seattle to downtown. This means you have a lot of shared stops, including the ones that the streetcar expansion were meant (in part) to provide. For example a trip from (roughly) Pioneer Square to South Lake Union. They both run every ten minutes midday. This means that they could easily be synchronized to provide 5 minute combined headways on their shared path. This is actually better than what the streetcar promised (where the combined headways ended at Westlake). Since the stops are already RapidRide (for the C Line) you don’t have to do anything extra for the H Line expansion.

          I go into more detail here: https://seattletransitblog.com/2024/10/04/replacing-the-south-lake-union-streetcar/

        3. They’re job centers and you need good transit for job centers like SLU and First Hill with major employers.

          Right, and from a pure transit perspective, we are better off replacing the streetcars with buses. The buses would have much better routing than the flawed streetcars and more right-of-way.

        4. Outside of a restructure there’s some very low hanging fruit too: the 40 and C should share stops on 3rd, and Lenora/Blanchard should have 24/7 bus lanes.

        5. “ Seriously though, West Seattle Link won’t reach downtown until 2042, assuming there aren’t further delays.”

          That’s the party line. However building only north from SODO to the County buildings will require several years of tunneling and track work before 2042. The undiscussed construction phasing to me appears as though 1 Line will have to stop at SODO on the north end maybe as early as the West Seattle opening date. The tracks are NOT being planned to merely shift the 1 Line to the new tunnel on opening day.

          Of course, ST could lay out SODO Station and approach tracks differently — but they just won’t consider it. And only a few like me plead for it.

          The revised EIS should hopefully shed some light on the phasing.

      2. But we need a better solution for going to South Lake Union. The current streetcar isn’t cutting it.

        What Mike wrote. We should be able to provide good service from the rest of downtown to South Lake Union (SLU) with the buses. Even if the light rail line was built it wouldn’t add much for SLU. Denny is definitely worth covering and from an abstract standpoint it an excellent station. The train will be paired with the one from Rainier Valley. If you are coming from south of downtown (SoDo, Beacon Hill, Rainier Valley, etc.) then it is a very nice addition. The same is true of the so-called South Lake Union and Seattle Center stations. But none of that makes up for the fact that you now have to transfer to get to the UW (as well as Capitol Hill, Roosevelt, etc.). Thus riders from the south are worse off, despite this strong station.

        Since the trains will be coming from Rainier Valley, they will run infrequently (every ten minutes). Taking the train from the south end of downtown to Denny is probably not worth it. Maybe if you are going from right next to a station to right next to a station but that is rare. Taking a more frequent bus (on the surface) is better for the vast majority of trips.

        The same is true of transfers. Coming from the north (e. g. the UW) it makes sense to just use the 8. Coming from the East Side you would have to deal with the very time-consuming transfer at Westlake. SoDo is the only station where the transfers will be pretty good and even then there will be plenty of people in West Seattle who will just get off their train at Westlake and walk a few blocks north. The train to Ballard (sorry, Seattle Center) won’t be frequent. The buses can be.

        The so called South Lake Union station is different. It is far enough away to be worth taking the train, even with a transfer. The problem is, it is in a very poor location. It is meant to connect to Aurora buses. If the train had a station at Harrison & Westlake it would provide good coverage for much of South Lake Union. It will instead be at Harrison & 7th (at best). This provides less coverage for the urban part of South Lake Union while more coverage for low-density areas to the east (Memorial Stadium parking lot, Gates Foundation*, space for Aurora, etc.). It also overlaps the coverage area of the Denny station. This is one of the big drawbacks with Ballard Link. Going straight and then abruptly turning is not good. You provide very little additional coverage while increasing costs substantially. This is what I mean when I say Ballard Link is fragile. The details matter a great deal (and they didn’t get them right at either Denny or South Lake Union). This is in contrast with the main line, where they didn’t get the details right at the UW but it worked out OK anyway.

        Then you have the Seattle Center Station, which will be at Uptown. This is arguably the best station in the entire West Seattle/Ballard line (now that it won’t go to Ballard). I just don’t think especially since it overlaps the coverage area of the monorail.

        That’s the problem with the current plan. When the dust settles and we have this line from Uptown to West Seattle it will be a nice improvement. There will be plenty of trips that will be significantly faster. But the vast majority of ridership will come from forcing riders off of their bus at Westlake. Investing a tiny portion of the money in the buses would be a lot more valuable. You would get a lot more new transit riders and existing riders would save a lot more time.

        *This is not meant as a criticism of the Gates Foundation or its workers. They are doing an excellent job. But the building itself is in the style of a suburban office park and thus lacks density compared to typical buildings in South Lake Union.

        1. There should be a bus shuttle route going back and forth between IDS and SLU in the 99 tunnel. Alternatively, the monorail could have an intermediate stop just at about Wall Street.

      3. “But we need a better solution for going to South Lake Union. The current streetcar isn’t cutting it.”

        Except the proposed Ballard Link has eliminated the station that’s actually in South Lake Union. The closest it gets is Denny or Aurora. Sure, I guess that’s sort of close, but it’s closer to Seattle Center than it is to SLU.

    7. “One solution Sound Transit seriously needs to look into is rerouting Ballard Link to UW”

      This was proposed a bunch of times by folks on this blog (as well as former Ballard councilmember Mike O’Brien) and was the most popular of the Ballard routes according to a ST poll. Then SDOT Kubly put forward (without public comment) his two tunnel proposal and Seattle Subway and STB considered him the smartest man in the room, if not the city.

      My guess is Ballard to UW is not part of what people voted for in ST3 (did we really vote for 2062 or a station on 14th?), so it is off the table until ST4 next century.

      1. I hate to be this much of a “downer”, but humanity’s continuance for three-quarters of a century longer is truly questionable. Civilization’s continuance is almost certain to fail before then.

      2. The initial advocacy was for a Ballard-UW line. At the time ST3 was a vague future concept, with no timeline or routes. ST2 included studies for several potential corridors, including Ballard-UW and Ballard-downtown. People assumed those studies and the vote would occur in the 2020s when ST2 was winding down. Mayor Mike McGinn championed Link to Ballard but preferred a Ballard-downtown line, so that was the only one he’d support. It would have gone through Belltown, not SLU.

        McGinn pressed the board to accelerate the Ballard-downtown study, and paid ST to also study an SLU streetcar extension/upgrade to Ballard at the same time (via Westlake Ave N and Leary Way NW, serving Fremont). The other subareas said, “We want to accelerate our projects too.” So they all proceeded to draw up ST3.

        I don’t remember whether Kubly was SDOT director yet at that time. But he was never mentioned in this; it was all McGinn.

        1. Kubly was Ed Murray’s SDOT (I won’t even mention STB’s requiem for Murray after he had to resign in disgrace) head and he is the one who wrote to ST as Seattle’s Transportation head that proposed two tunnels (which was in the ST3 proposal). McGinn’s proposal went through Belltown IIRC, but did not have the Big Tech suggestion of SLU. SLU was a Big Tech/Kubly vehicle, not McGinn.

  4. The focus needs to shift to discussing DSTT2 transfers. Extensions are much less problematic to postpone while fixing bad transfers is very difficult and can take 100 years to fix.

    The “reach Ballard” idea has merit — but if the transfers Downtown remain this awful, riding a RapidRide bus becomes easier and better for future riders.

  5. The parade of speakers listed here says to me that this is primarily a PR event and not a place to consider useful public feedback. It’s to placate outraged Ballard residents and that’s it. They dangle this unrealistic 2042 date to imply that dissent means delay and give false hope — knowing in advance that they don’t have the tens of billions needed to build this rider-unfriendly tan mahal that’s hell to actually use .

    It makes me sick that Seattlites put up with these ultimately phony ST “forums” . ST and these Board members do not dare risk changing what they already want to do (in my opinion).

    1. The target date estimate is because Strauss insisted on adding this requirement to the May realignment (I forget the term for the reset). A public hearing is because ST normally does this, and it may be a requirement to have community engagement on it. The “parade of speakers” and “PR event” sound like overreading into it when you don’t even know what the speakers will say.

      I can’t believe Strauss is doing all this just for PR. He wants a target date because he’s passionate about Ballard and for his constituents. He wants to publicize it for the same reason. I wish he were more skeptical on ST’s preferred alignment alternative rather than just saying “Finish it!” (“Build the damn trains” even), but let’s not let the perfect be the enemy of the good.

      In any case, it’s a chance to fire questions back at the panel where the senator, boardmembers, mayor, and councilmembers will hear them directly. They can’t hide and pretend they didn’t hear them. So it’s important to have some high-quality questions and suggestions ready. Of course, there may be no Q&A, but maybe we can force one.

      Also in any case, a target date is better than no date, and seeing the estimates/assumptions it’s based on is better than not having those.

      1. You’re more hopeful than I am , Mike.

        Nine “speakers” is a lot. If the panel was five transit experts that aren’t elected it would be different. Put Kubly, Jarrett Walker, Nick Andert, a seasoned retired urban rail designer and Ray Delahanty on a discussion panel and it would be quite enlightening. But these are nine former or currently elected officials. They will want to fill as much time as possible to avoid any challenging questions. They’ll be lucky to have time for more than a few softball questions that will be drafted and likely given to them beforehand.

        They know that they’re shortchanging Ballard folk. I think they do these stunts to quell questioning about their unrealistic hopes to make Ballard Link happen in a more affordable way.

        1. The irony is that Ballard Link could “happen in a more affordable way” in a shorter time-frame. But that involves challenging settled decisions which government only does in wartime when its side is losing. And even it’s rare.

      2. Every Sound Transit Board meeting begins with an opportunity for public comment. While the big meeting in May was packed, I have seen meetings with only 3 people signed up. Like with much public comment, Board members likely ignore most of these comments, but it’s hard for them to totally shut their ears, so it’s probably just as good a chance to influence them as at one of these PR events, where there may not be much, if any, genuine Q&A. If people want to communicate with the decision makers directly, the public comment section of regular Board meetings seems like an underused opportunity to do so (of course, this presumes people don’t have to be at work at the time the Board meets). This is not to say that having a big turnout of well-informed constituents attending the Ballard forum doesn’t matter. Having said all that, it’s hard to imagine what public input could get them to change course at this point. Probably only external shocks like a further doubling of the DSTT2’s cost, or the State repealing their tax authority beyond existing bonds, or a strong signal from the feds that x project will get major funding support but y project will get zero.

        1. Some forums have simple Q&As at the end where people line up to as a question. I don’t remember whether the ST open houses with presentations have that. They must take some questions for when people don’t understand the content.

          Testimony at an ST board meeting is a different thing. It’s a legal requirement for public engagement, and the testimony is recorded to prove that engagement and theoretically to inform the board. Speakers are declaring an opinion for two minutes, not asking a question for ten seconds. There are usually so many speakers that it takes over an hour if the topic is a major Link decision.

          The problem with this format is it’s right immediately before the board discussion and vote. Realistically, boardmembers need to have researched the issue and solidified their position before that point. In the unlikely case a speaker changes a boardmember’s position, the new position may not be well thought out because it was made in the space of an hour with only the speaker’s information, which may be incomplete or inaccurate.

          So the real time to influence the board is early in the process, when the board is asking what’s needed.

          This Ballard situation is unusual because the financial shortfall is forcing the project into phases that won’t start for years. This gives an opportunity to argue to reopen the decisions. That’s what attendees can do at this forum.

    2. ST is not open to external ideas. Maybe they would be if the Board hadn’t let Dow Constantine attempt to become the next Joni Earl while also being a primary source of many of the agency’s current issues.

      Cynically, I think this is absolutely nothing more than a PR event, and I think Dan Strauss is spending a lot of political capital on it so he has something to run his reelection campaign on next year.

      However, I think it is an opportunity for advocates to bring some sharp questions to the speakers. I just hope someone is recording it.

      1. Strauss hasn’t had any serious opposition since his election. Unlike Mike O’Brien, Strauss hasn’t picked a fight with the Shilshole/Missing Link businesses so he has the job as long as he wants it.

        1. It’s hard to imagine a better candidate given the council average and previous candidates. Councilmembers like Strauss are few and far between.

    3. Yes, that is a reasonable apprehension. But Strauss held a similar event in the spring and there was time for significant public comment. Some officials know to leave time for the public.

  6. Cost-savings? Axe Graham St, Boeing, TCC and all of East Link.

    Also, the North Line is slated to end in 2032 (i forgot where I read that recently). If ST knows it’s a non-ridership-generator and drain on resources, why not kill it now? Not sure how much all of that adds up but it’s a starter…

    1. Axe …all of East Link.

      Are folks referring to the South Kirkland-Issaquah Link Extension as “East Link” now? The original “East Link” hasn’t even been open for a full year and it’s already losing its name?

      Also, the North Line is slated to end in 2032 (i forgot where I read that recently). If ST knows it’s a non-ridership-generator and drain on resources, why not kill it now?

      You probably read it here: https://seattletransitblog.com/2026/05/08/sounder-north-might-end-in-2033/

      Cynically: Sound Transit Board Chair Dave Somers can’t run for reelection in 2028 due to term limits, so it’s long enough after his tenure that it won’t be his problem. He doesn’t want his legacy to be reduced transit service in Snohomish County, so he punted the issue to the next County Executive.

      Generously: Everett Link is expected to start construction in 2030, so it’s likely that the financial estimates after ~2033 just couldn’t support funding operations of the Sounder N Line and the financial weight of heavy civil construction. Other than some systemwide operational needs, money generated by ST taxes in Snohomish County are expected to be spent by ST within Snohomish County, so they have to live within those cashflow limitations for the long-range plan.

      1. Doesn’t SoHoCo still have a positive balance with North King? East King paid for almost all of East Link, so if there’s a balance due there it’s pretty small. But Sno paid into the till for many years while they ran their own express buses to avoid raiding the kitty for Link. Link from the County Line to Lynnwood couldn’t have cost much more than $4 billion even with the Skycastles. And Sounder North, though the capital cost was ridiculous, can’t cost too much. Gemini says it’s less than a million a month.

        Chump change.

        1. Chump change.

          Well, ST is the chump looking for change in this situation, so it seems that they need to take all they can get. A dozen years of Sounder N Line operations might be a rounding error, but when faced with a requirement to publish a balanced long-range budget, perhaps the N Line’s cost was the straw that broke the bottom line.

          It’s so inconsequential otherwise I can’t imagine why Somers would include it in the assumptions unless it was technically justifiable.

      1. This. It allows a shallow New Westlake (and Denny Way, too) that (maybe someday, over the rainbow) can be extended into First Hill about Seneca. If the savings by axing DSTT2 south of New Westlake, the line on the busway and the Skycastle at Lander don’t save quite enough, choose a mid-level opening bridge and live with the occasional delays.

        “Mid-level” does not have to mean “as low as the existing Ballard Bridge”. Add twenty feet and it will only rarely open. This saves a bundle vis-a-vis a high bridge and two bundles compared to a tunnel.

        P.S. Has anyone figured out how deeply a tunnel in the Fourteenth or Fifteenth right-of-way has to dive to get under the whale sized holding tunnel along the north shore? Since Fourteenth and Fifteenth are not flat north of the Ship Canal, it would probably force pretty deep platforms at Ballard Station, while a mid-level bridge and elevated station could have platforms just one-and-a-half stories up if it uses side-platforms. Or two stories with a “non-soaring” mezzanine.

        1. Has anyone figured out how deeply a tunnel in the Fourteenth or Fifteenth right-of-way has to dive to get under the whale sized holding tunnel along the north shore?

          Yes, they accommodated it in the WSBLE conceptual drawings. The holding tunnel was a main reason why they didn’t advance any designs west of the Ballard Bridge.

          I think they Market Street Station is supposed to be similar in depth to Capitol Hill Station. IIRC from my time on the Interbay-Ballard Community Advisory Group, the station also has to be deep to get its tail track under the subsurface parking garage & office building north of Market Street (where there was an “urban” Target for a few years). Of course, they could (and should) go the route they did with Alaska Junction and nix the tail track if it lets the station get closer to the surface, but we won’t know what they’re cooking until the DEIS comes out.

    2. “Cost-savings? Axe Graham St, Boeing, TCC and all of East Link.”

      First of all, Katie Wilson, Girmay Zahilay, and Teresa Mosqueda just saved Graham St Station and there’s nothing we can do about it. Graham St Station is a high priority area and cutting it would be the equivalent of not having the 597 stop in Rainier Valley and having the light rail alignment along MLK at-grade.

      Boeing Access Road? Sure buddy, take it. No one will use it anyway.

      TCC? Just sell the T Line to the City of Tacoma and let them do what they want with it.

      For “East Link”, just cut the part from Bellevue Downtown to South Kirkland (which people can use the K Line), have it go to South Bellevue Station rather than run along I-405, and have it run at-grade along I-90. Reconfigure Central Issaquah station to be closer to the transit center and permanently defer Lakemont. Lakemont’s density is so low it doesn’t deserve a funded study. Instead study an extension that might be worth something, like Issaquah Highlands.

      “If ST knows it’s a non-ridership-generator and drain on resources, why not kill it now?”

      Exactly. I guess they just want to give current N Line riders some time to prepare for the axe and 2033 will be the 30th anniversary of the N Line.

        1. “Or it’s when the agreement with BNSF expires.”

          Sound Transit paid BNSF to run commuter rail from Everett to Seattle, and that was forever.

          You didn’t say anything about this, but Sound Transit really can’t get their money back by cancelling Sounder North. They’re really just saving up on parking improvements and operating costs (which makes no sense as ST3’s shortfall is capital).

        2. There are shorter operational agreements in addition to the permanent easement. BNSF operates Sounder trains. That agreement is for several years and then has to be renewed, like the Seattle Transit Measure.

        3. “Sound Transit really can’t get their money back by cancelling Sounder North.”

          Why not? BNSF would be keen to have more freight capacity.

  7. I have what I think is a good question someone could ask at this forum. It goes something like this …

    “On September 14th, Sound Transit put out an announcement saying they are seeking cost-saving ideas for Ballard Link. To quote My Ballard, ‘Sound Transit is looking for ideas that could reduce costs or speed up the delivery of light rail projects still in the planning phase, including the Ballard Link extension.’ My question is, what are some of the best Ballard Link ideas you received?”

  8. Pushing Ballard Link all the way to 2060 is completely unacceptable for a line voters approved back in 2016. I’m glad Strauss is hosting this forum, but Sound Transit needs to find real cost-saving solutions rather than endlessly kicking the can down the road.

  9. Pushing the Ballard line out to 2060 is completely unacceptable for a project voters approved back in 2016. I really hope neighbors show up to this forum and press Strauss on finding actual solutions rather than just kicking the can down the road.

  10. Pushing the completion date out to 2060 is completely unacceptable for transit voters approved back in 2016. Hopefully this forum focuses on real, practical cost-saving alternatives so Ballard can actually see light rail in our lifetimes.

Comments are closed.