An idea I have rattling around in my seemingly-touched head, is to suggest a safe way to re-open travel between these two interconnected cities.
The idea has its nadir in the proposal by WTA prior to I-695’s (and 9/11’s) damage, to operate a joint service with TransLink between Bellingham and Vancouver. Transit Windsor’s TunnelBus service is further inspiration vis-a-vis preclearance.
In this idea, the concept would be to have a pre-clearance site at Fairhaven and at Pacific Central Station. Passengers would be screened and boarded onto a Coast Mountain Bus Company coach, and driven directly to the other terminus, with a 5 minute stop at the Port of Entry, using the priority screening lane. This would allow the route to have a predictable schedule, without having to pad for severe delays.
What had been pushed to the community as a major service expansion appears to me to be a significant service cut.
The current system:
The proposed system:
What the consultants were working off of (the BFT Board Visioning Retreat)
From my perspective, the main issues with the Ben Franklin Transit Comprehensive Service Plan proposal as a service restructure are thus:
1. It appears to have been developed by individuals who did not actually ride the system in service. The plan is in effect unimplementable.
2. The system shifts from a neighborhood focus to a regional focus, something that may seem workable to someone who isn’t transit-dependent, but in how the Tri-Cities is laid out will not work as proposed. It is applied in a manner which will in my educated opinion result in a ridership death spiral. It will result in dramatically increased service costs as recovery time will be far too elastic to schedule to a pulse. There is needless duplication. Nobody will trade a one-seat ride for inaccessibility to regional cultural attractions such as Columbia Park and The Reach. There is no night service to Columbia Center or Queensgate.
3. 15 minute corridors have multiple route numbers assigned to them. This makes it less apparent that there’s frequent service in that corridor. Take the SR240 causeway between I-82 and Columbia Park Trail as an example. Rather than using a single route number for this route, the consultants propose extending a local route in Richland (the 26) to augment the 120. This won’t end well as rush hour traffic would hopelessly ensnare the 26 and significantly deteriorate service. This also confuses the existing ridership and does not give the perception of frequent service to a visitor. Further, in Kennewick on Clearwater Avenue, there is another 15 minute corridor except in this case it is only 15 minutes Monday through Friday. Saturday Service will be split between two routes each running on 60 minute intervals. In other words the 150 will run every 30 minutes Monday through Friday, though only every 60 minutes on Saturdays. The 160 would be operated the same way. The existing ridership would understand this to be a significant service cut.
4. This may just be an innocent oversight, however the plan mentions 7 day service on the summary page, though only discusses Monday-Saturday service on the route proposals.
5. Nothing beyond a cryptic answer of “Taxi Feeder” is given for how service will be provided to those areas which lose service. This is a very costly solution which may not be workable or safe. The existing contractor is deficient in their provision of service, to which BFT is not responsive to substantially deal with.
Ben Franklin Transit Proposed Route Network
I have been working on this project some more, and it should be interactive now.
The individual routes have some information in their bubbles, pertaining to proposed headways and service spans.
It is a work in progress, which I wish I could input into Remix (but then Remix has disappeared into the ether, with no offline contact information)
From the Island Transit website front page http://www.islandtransit.org
At the July 24, 2015 Board of Directors meeting, the Island Transit Board voted to continue the 411W and 411C as currently run, until word was received from the Governor’s office that the previously-approved $2.3M for the route, aka the “Tri-County Connector”, was available. We have now received confirmation from Governor Inslee’s office that he will protect transit funding in the new transportation bill.
There has been a continuing discussion relating to the Fare Study the WSDOT is doing for Island. Once the study has been completed, funds will be released to re-instate the 412.
I’ve been working on this for a while. There are still a few routes to input.
Ben Franklin Transit route restructure proposal