The Pro-Transit Case for Governance Reform

This post originally appeared on Orphan Road.

Martin says that governance reform is a bad idea. And it is! I really thought that this issue was settled and done with, but apparently not, as Susan Hutchison is still making noises about it in her run for County Executive.

That said, there is probably a case to be made for some kind of governance reform, just not the kind advocated in the Rice-Stanton report. Rice-Stanton recommends:

  • Giving Sound Transit authority over regional road mega-projects (which ought to be funded by the state and/or tolls), and
  • Creating a 15-member oversight board (which would be stacked with anti-transit folks from Olympia and special-interest electeds, as Martin notes)

A better reform would involve:

  • Keeping road authority where it is
  • Incorporating most (if not all) of the county bus systems (Metro, Pierce, Community, etc.)*
  • Making the board appointed by mayors and/or County Execs in the region

Such a system would be not unlike New York’s MTA or Philly’s SEPTA, which have regional rail responsibility but also handle transit within the city. You’d have to balance the need to serve rural communities with keeping the RTA boundary intact, but it could be made to work.

Of course, such a system would be way too powerful, too pro-transit and too pro-urban to actually get approved in Olympia. Plus, as Martin notes, Sound Transit has work to do… why mess with it? And finally, making the case for reform just adds to the pro-reform noises. I don’t want to be a useful idiot for the other side.

So, onward and upward, Sound Transit!

* Contra Hutchison, Rice-Stanton doesn’t actually recommend integrating transit agencies. It simply suggests further studying the issue.

Meet-up Details

citysearch.com
citysearch.com

As promised, here are the details.  The meet-up will be in the back area of the Columbia City Ale House this Thursday, August 6.

Importantly, you can take Link there if you’re willing to walk about 4 blocks.  You can also get a discount on their “Light Rail Ale” if you present an Orca Card or Link ticket.  As an added bonus, the restrooms are transit-themeed.

I’ll be there to receive people no later than 6 pm.  We’ll have a guest speaker that should get started by about 7.

If you’re planning to attend, please say so in the comments.  21 and over only, unfortunately.

Why Governance Reform is a bad idea

County Exec candidate Susan Hutchinson (and to a lesser extent Ross Hunter) have made some approving comments about governance reform.  Governance reform refers to a whole class of proposals that involves the merger of various transportation agencies to introduce operating efficiencies.  The most well-known of these is the Rice/Stanton proposal, which would have created a transportation super-agency responsible for roads and transit in a four county area  (King, Pierce, Snohomish, Kitsap).  The 15-member board would be a mixture of directly elected members and the Governor’s appointees.  This proposal, and others like it, is a terrible idea.

For clarity, I’ll focus on the Rice/Stanton proposal, but many of these arguments apply to other reorganization ideas:

Continue reading “Why Governance Reform is a bad idea”

Housekeeping Note

This post originally appeared on Orphan Road.

I’ve upgraded the software that runs Orphan Road to try and deal with some spam issues that you may have seen on the site. There are also some anti-spam measures in the registration process. As part of all this, I’ve been deleting hundreds of spam user registrations that have shown up in the last month. I’m trying very hard to not delete “real” people, but in the unlikely event that I delete your account, please accept my sincerest apologies in advance.

Oh, and bloggers should have an easier time uploading images to the blog. Let me know how that works.

Sunday Open Thread

KBFI
"KBFI US NAVY Blue Angels", by wings777

I rode Link to Othello yesterday for a quick look at people riding to and from Seafair. My train was well used with lots of people and bikes. Then I went to Alki for some fish-and-chips. I had to go back downtown and catch a bus. It made me wish there were better east-west connections.

In a totally unrelated note, South Seattle hip-hop duo Blue Scholars, the same guys who brought us our official theme song “Joe Metro”, have a short video featuring Link light rail. The video has their DJ Sabzi riding Link on opening weekend (sorry, I’m having trouble embedding it). At the end of the video he announces a new partnership with Duck Down Records and Caffe Vita for their upcoming projects. I hope to see another video or song featuring Seattle’s newest form of transit in the future.

This is an open thread.

Getting the 520 Band Back Together

This post originally appeared on Orphan Road.

The P-I’s Scott Gutierrez reports that the working group who will figure out how to finance and build the new SR 520 floating bridge will meet this week.

This seems like as good a time as any to revisit the three options (A, K and L) still under consideration. Helpfully, WSDOT has posted fly-through simulations of each.

First, in this corner, clocking in at a svelte $4.8 billion, is Option A:

Next, topping the scales at a whopping $6.7 billion, is Option K:

And finally, playing the role of “just right” Goldilox at $5.1 billion, is Option L:

You can read about the differences here.